Epic formally asks SCOTUS to uphold contempt ruling against Apple
By Marcus Mendes
 
Epic Games has submitted its official response to Apple's Supreme Court
appeal, urging the justices to uphold the contempt ruling over App Store
payment restrictions. Here are the details.

A bit of context
As most 9to5Mac readers probably know, Apple and Epic Games have been
engaged in a lengthy legal battle since 2020, when Epic sued Apple after
Fortnite was removed from the App Store.

The move came after Epic remotely activated an alternative payment system
that bypassed Apple's In-App Purchase system.
Although the court largely sided with Apple, it did rule that the company
could no longer prevent developers from directing users to alternative
payment methods outside the App Store.
Apple ultimately allowed those links, but imposed new restrictions,
including a 27% commission on external purchases, in addition to new rules
limiting how developers could display buttons and links to alternative
payment methods.

Epic challenged those restrictions, and the court agreed that Apple had
violated the original injunction, holding the company in civil contempt.
Apple has since attempted multiple times to overturn that ruling, arguing
that the original injunction contained no explicit prohibition on imposing
those restrictions.
Epic, on the other hand, argues that Apple deliberately circumvented the
court order by introducing new rules designed to achieve the same result as
those originally prohibited.
In May, Apple appealed to the Supreme Court, which agreed in June to hear
the case. Apple submitted its opening brief in September, followed by
supporting briefs from the U.S. government and several legal and business
groups.
Those included the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Chamber of Progress, and
several former federal antitrust enforcers. In a nutshell, the U.S.
government argued that the original injunction did not clearly prohibit
Apple's 27% commission on external purchases, but maintained that the
company was correctly held in contempt for restricting how developers could
display external payment buttons.

Today, Epic filed its official response.
Epic's official response
In its opening brief, Apple argues, citing multiple legal precedents, that
courts must enforce the letter of an injunction rather than its broader
spirit.
According to the company, there was nothing in the original injunction
explicitly prohibiting it from charging commissions on external purchases or
imposing additional restrictions on payment links, so it should not be held
in contempt for conduct that the court order did not clearly prohibit.

In its response filed today, Epic disputes Apple's interpretation of the
injunction, arguing that the company "attempts to avoid contempt by
proposing an extreme legal standard."
>From the filing:
[Apple] argues that a court can find contempt only if an injunction spells
out the exact practice at issue-so an injunction barring Apple's
then-existing anti-steering rules left it free to implement new ones that
prevent steering just as effectively. Nothing in this Court's precedents
supports that approach, which would reduce injunctions to a never-ending
game of whack-a-mole.

Epic argues that "Apple devised a plan to circumvent the injunction,"
claiming that "Apple chose a rate of 27% for the commission, knowing that,
when combined with the developers' payment-handling costs (more than 3%),
the rate for linked-out purchases would be higher than the rate for
purchases using Apple's payment system."
Epic writes:
As an Apple executive admitted, every "linked-out transaction is going to be
more expensive to any developer * * * than an IAP transaction at 30
percent." Apple simultaneously commissioned a "sham" report to try to
provide an economic justification for the commission; the report contained
an "entirely manufactured" rationale for the 27% rate.

The company also argues that "Apple tried to cover up its scheme to
circumvent the injunction" by asserting privilege over more than 57,000
documents, and points to Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers' finding that "its
Vice President of Finance 'outright lied under oath' when he testified about
when Apple decided to impose the new commission."

Finally, Epic asks the Supreme Court to uphold the contempt ruling against
Apple or, if the justices decide to clarify the legal standard for contempt,
to send the case back to the lower courts for reconsideration under that
standard.

With Epic's response now filed, Apple has until December 14 to submit its
final brief before oral arguments take place on January 11, 2027.

You can read Epic's full document below:

Original Article at:
https://9to5mac.com/2026/11/13/epic-formally-asks-scotus-to-uphold-contempt-
ruling-against-apple/


-- 
The following information is important for all members of the V iPhone list.

If you have any questions or concerns about the running of this list, or if you 
feel that a member's post is inappropriate, please contact the owners or 
moderators directly rather than posting on the list itself.

Your V iPhone list moderator is Mark Taylor.  Mark can be reached at:  
[email protected].  Your list owner is Cara Quinn - you can reach Cara 
at [email protected]

The archives for this list can be searched at:
http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/
--- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"VIPhone" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To view this discussion visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/viphone/000901dd755f%24ad723970%240856ac50%24%40commandlevel.com.

Reply via email to