Yaron,

The interface multiplexing can be achieved using macvlan driver or using an 
SR-IOV capable NIC (the preferred option), macvlan may need to be extended to 
support VEPA multicast handling, this looks like a rather simple task 

Agreed that the hardware solution is preferred so the macvlan implementation 
doesn’t really matter.  If we are talking SR-IOV, then it is direct mapped, 
regardless of whether there is a VEB or VEPA in the hardware below, so you are 
bypassing the bridge software code also.  

I disagree that adding the multicast handling is simple – while not 
conceptually hard, it will basically require you to put an address table into 
the macvlan implementation – if you have that, then why not have just used the 
one already in the bridge code.  If you hook a VEPA up to a non-hairpin mode 
external bridge, you get the macvlan capability as well.

It also seems to me like the special macvlan interfaces for KVM don’t apply to 
XEN or a non-virtualized environment?  Or more has to be written to make that 
work?  If it is in the bridge code, you get all of this re-use.

 

 

_______________________________________________
Virtualization mailing list
Virtualization@lists.linux-foundation.org
https://lists.linux-foundation.org/mailman/listinfo/virtualization

Reply via email to