Dear All,

I was using the MINUS clause together with the TRANSITIVE option,
and I found an incorrect behavior.

1) I insert some triples as follow:

insert into <teste>
{
<GRANDFATHER> a owl:Class.
<FATHER> a owl:Class.
<SON> a owl:Class.
<SON> rdfs:subClassOf <FATHER>
<FATHER> rdfs:subClassOf <GRANDFATHER>
}

2) I list the owl:Class subjects

SELECT ?s
FROM <teste>
WHERE
{
?s a owl:Class.
}

 s  FATHER  GRANDFATHER  SON

3) I list the subClass of the subject <FATHER> with the TRANSITIVE option
enable

SELECT ?s
FROM <teste>
WHERE
{
?s rdfs:subClassOf <FATHER> OPTION (TRANSITIVE, t_distinct,
t_step('step_no') as ?n, t_min (0) ).
}

 s  FATHER  SON

4) I applied the MINUS clause in order to obtain the owl:Class subject
"minus" the ones obtained in the query #3

SELECT ?s
FROM <teste>
WHERE
{
?s a owl:Class.
MINUS
{
?s rdfs:subClassOf <FATHER> OPTION (TRANSITIVE, t_distinct,
t_step('step_no') as ?n, t_min (0) ).
}
}

*Result: NONE*
*
*
I was expecting just *GRANDFATHER*
*
*
Am I doing something wrong?
*
*
Best Regards,

Percy

Reply via email to