The Toshiba battery technology is very impressive and will be a bonanza for
them and lots of gadgets, but before one goes overboard about the electric
automobile, do your arithmetic.

Jed is spot on in remembering my caution about electric filling stations. On
a turnpike, you pull lin and in five minutes get refilled with the energy to
travel some 300 miles at 80 mph in 3.75 hours. The actual power delivered to
the wheels is not bad, say 20 kW. So that's (3.75)(20) = 75 kWH to be
delivered to the battery in 1/12 hour, at a rate of (75)(12) = 900 kW, which
will vaporize the battery. Think about this carefully, and multiply by 10
cars at a time. Ot think about it in a remote rural station on the road from
nowhere to nowhere else.

Now if you are going to deliver the same energy, 75 kWH overnight, say 12
hours, that's only a 6.25 kW rate. With 200+ volt service it's only 31+
amperes from your utility, about 8 horsepower.

You can spin these numbers many ways, and they don't apply to crawling in
metropolitan commuter traffic, where electric cars can perform very
efficiently -- as long as you don't use the heater or air conditioner. It is
worthwhile to understand that the cooling capcity of a car air conditioner
is comparable with a whole house system. Don't be misled by its compactness.
The compressor can draw some four horsepower from the engine, much more than
a home compressor. The car air conditoner has to chill you quick and keep
you cool on a hot road in the hot sun with an inefficient furnace in front
of you. For an electric car, the furnace isn't there and insulation can be
better.

The current litium ion technology is expensive. Lead acid batteries are good
for delivering huge current surges necessary for starters and highway
passing. I assume lithium ion batteries can be designed for automotive
service.

Mike Carrell



Reply via email to