I'm glad it was published.

I think it is unlikely that a theorist is going to find the complete theory in 
one simple step. In the same way it is unlikely that the first simple 
experiment will create just the right complete conditions for perfect LENR. But 
each one of these theories and experiments provide new ideas and data points 
that may well contribute to the final understanding of the phenomena.

I was fascinated by the use of Alfvén waves as an analogy to explain 
Ponderomotive forces at atomic level in solids. I'm also curious about the 
neutron spalation issues etc discussed here. I'm sure they are well aware if 
those issues so I hope they can expand on that and explain here someday. It 
seems they have in mind that the neutrons are coupled with the lower mass 
Nickel somehow perhaps in a collective way as they say the lower energy Ni 58 
are filled first. I'm curious if they can explain more about that

It might be in the end there is a simple and unusual but it seems more likely 
to me the over all solution is likely it is complex in the system and made up 
of particular combinations of processes in specific conditions. As Ed Storms 
and many others have said this would explain why we do not se it under normal 
circumstances but only in very specific conditions and places. It seems likely 
to me that at theory level too it will take a special combination of current 
ideas and concepts.

I hope that the exceptional knowledge providers, theorist and experimenters 
alike who present here and elsewhere are always are able to raise there ideas 
for discussion without fear of being wrong or incomplete and also to be open to 
both the critical and supporting discussions that result as that way we are 
more likely to find the right combination that explains LENR. And more than 
likely there are bits of truth in every idea.

With out hearing these ideas and discussing them a critical piece might be 
missed. Ponderomotive forces could be one of those.


> On 17 okt. 2015, at 15:39, Mats Lewan <[email protected]> wrote:
> 
> Several weaknesses in the paper presented by Lundin and Lidgren have been 
> discussed here, as it should be.
> When I gave attention to the paper on my blog I expected such weaknesses to 
> be discovered and exposed. However, my reason for giving publicity to the 
> paper were three:
> 
> - the authors’ claim that they had made a successful, albeit non documented, 
> experiment, indicating that they might have found some kind of useful method. 
> I had hoped that they would have made their planned real experiment before 
> presenting the paper.
> - the fairy novel introduction of the little-known phenomenon of 
> ponderomotive forces in the LENR field.
> - the fact that their paper wouldn’t even be considered for traditional 
> peer-review, which is sad since only increased exchange of ideas in this 
> field, where so many cross competences apparently are needed, will lead to 
> progress.
> 
> Also compare with Edward de Bono’s concept of Lateral Thinking (which I refer 
> to in the last chapter of my book) where one method of dealing with the 
> brains tendency to pick pieces of information, one at a time (and therefore 
> miss hidden paths if the pieces are presented in the ‘wrong’ order) is to 
> consider also apparently ‘impossible’ paths that normally would be discarded, 
> since they might lead to a possible and real goal, even though they pass 
> through forbidden areas. One way of doing this is trying to see valuable 
> pieces of a new proposition, even though the the theory as a whole might not 
> be valid.
> 
> As someone pointed out, such an attitude might also encourage the authors to 
> take part in the discussion here.
> 
> Mats
> www.animpossibleinvention.com
> 
> 
> 

Reply via email to