The guy's claiming that induced B in 'electrical steel' climbs to 500% of
applied H.

He's basically claiming runaway self-induction, apparently as an inherent
property of this material.

So what to make of it?  Applying an H field induces a B field, giving their
combined field density M, or net magnetisation.  If the H field is active
as from a coil or solenoid, Lenz's law applies and any change in induced B
applies back-EMF to the coil, thus loading its power supply.  If the H
field is passive however as from a permanent magnet, then the change in
induced B is thermodynamically 'free' - work is being done in reducing the
system entropy aligning domains, by absorbing phonons within the material -
one half of the magnetocaloric effect - and obvs, either way (active or
passive) at absolute zero no change in B is possible, so it looks like
we're not necessarily in controversial territory invoking ambient heat as a
potential source in a case of anomalous self-induction; we could even
invoke Sv in an example: place a small neo onto a piece of rough iron with
appreciable Sv, maybe amp it up to listen in on the Barkhausen jumps as
induced B starts to rise;  point is, induced B is rising AFTER all input
motion has ceased, hence where's the energy coming from to align the
domains against their mutual repulsion?  Because a magnetised material is
in a stressed state..  a higher energy state.  Yet if that energy isn't
coming from Mr Hand, then it's obvs environmental.  2LoT be damned.  In
certain circumstances, anyway.

So the only remaining question is:  how could B rise significantly higher
than applied H?

The question no longer where the energy's coming from, so much as the
magnetising field?  IE. even if we allow it free energy, how can the
induced field be 5x denser than the applied field?  What property might
'electrical steel' have that could facilitate a runaway
self-magnetisation?

Reply via email to