I agree with Ed's point that my analysis is not diagnostic of the LENR
process and will not help identify the nuclear active environment.
I think that we can only learn something about the collective endeavor
of LENR. We can learn something about the field of CMNS. My question is:
is the field at a critical point?
Criticality indicates the regime of complexity between chaos and order.
An Fe/H system is not complex in terms of LENR. Excess heat measurements
will center on a mean of 0W with some variance. This system is not
complex because there are not even any variables to understand in terms
of LENR. This may be the chaotic regime.
But a combustion engine is not complex either. All variables that
influence power generation are understood. It's controlled technology.
This may be the ordered regime.
The power-law of CMNS may indicate that the field is at a critical point
between non-technology (such as an Fe/H system) and controlled technology.
My hypothesis is, counter to Ed's statement, that combustion engines'
power outputs are normally distributed, not scale-invariant. I don't
expect extreme engines to exist that a power-law rather than an
exponential distribution describes the distribution. However, there may
be a power-law effect if different classes of cars are aggregated, as I
did with the LENR data.
This can be tested. Does someone have access to combustion engine power
data, possibly with an additional class variable?
Haiko
I appreciate the analysis Haiko did of the data I list in my book.
Before too much effort is spent on deciding what the power law Haiko
found means, we should consider several facts.
The values I listed are the maximum excess energy reported by each
listed study. This energy is based on a variety of temperatures of the
cathode, applied current density, simple size, and amount of NAE that
might have formed on the sample. Each of these variables is known to
affect the amount of excess energy produced. Therefore, the data do not
describe the same conditions. When a power law is applied, the same
conditions are assumed to exist. For example, if a phase transition is
being examined, the transition is always between the same two phases.
Instead, the CF reaction is occurring under a variety of conditions.
Nevertheless, the data appear to fit a power law. What can this mean
when these considerations are applied? I would like to suggest the
relationship means nothing. I suggest the same relationship could be
obtained by plotting many conditions in nature. For example, I expect
the same relationship can be obtained by plotting the number of gasoline
engines in service vs their horse power. Many small engines would be
found to exist and the number would drop as the size increased. A few
spikes might exist in the relationship at the popular sizes. Such a
relationship, although interesting, gives no basic understanding about
how gasoline engines work or why the different sizes were created.
The challenge no longer is to prove CF is real, which was the intent
behind making this list. The challenge now is to discover the
characteristics of the NAE. I don't think this relationship gives any
insight about how this can be done or how the NAE behaves under various
conditions.
Ed
On Oct 25, 2008, at 2:05 AM, Haiko Lietz wrote:
Dear colleagues,
I've taken a closer look at the 157 excess heat experiments collected by
Ed Storms in his 2007 book. The collective body of experiments
represents 1/f noise: many small events, few large ones. Kozima et al.
have found the same result for individual experiments. Now I want to
discuss the meaning of it. A short description of my analysis and my
questions are here:
http://complexity.haikolietz.de/?p=38
The website is public, so you may forward this to anyone who might have
something to contribute (or let me know who). This is a rather new type
of analysis and I hope to tap the "wisdom of the crows."
We can discuss this here on the list.
Many thanks
Haiko
--
Haiko Lietz
Science Reporter & Sociologist
complexity.haikolietz.de
www.haikolietz.de
Germany