[snip]
Nobody knows anything. There is no such thing as knowledge, because
knowledge
implies certainty, and there is always some element of doubt.

Come off it. Someone said that getting a PhD was a license to do research.
I'm not saying the state should ban non-initiates but there is the
Scientific Method.

1) Conjecture stage. Wacky idea. Wacky data. Wacky discovery. 

2) Hypothesis. You do some sums, read some books, talk to some people begin
to understand it or understand that you misunderstood it. You design future
experiments.

3) Theory/theorem stage. The data comes in and there is no other way to
explain it. You attach a theorem to the data and it matches to so many s.f.
(that's significant figures not science fiction, right?) and it achieves
general acceptance

4) Outreach stage. The clever people come along and look at it in all
different ways from different directions and see it ties up with other
stuff. They reformulate it and beauties of economy and other predictions
come out.

No, go find a Hydrino. Go look at spectrums from stars. Try and isolate the
stuff. Get a few uL of it. Do diffraction testing, find out how big they
are. Compress it and do a thermodynamic analysis of it so you can get its
equation of state. That'll give you an idea of how big the particles are too
and the forces they exert amongst each other. Try getting its emission
spectrum and tie it up with your astronomical data. Tackle the problem in
several directions and get the data to tie up.


He doesn't do any of this on his 60M$ dollar budget because he doesn't know
what he is doing or he is vain and wants to push a theory or it just doesn't
bloody exist.

If all you say all day is f..king hydrino, hydrino, hydrino on the john, on
the wife, on the au pair, squeezing your zits, having a w.nk, then I would
say you based your whole project on it and it was pretty damn central. So
your objective would be to nail that one right away. Right? 

Having met that milestone it would get generally accepted.

But you don't like certainty? Not even CERTAINTY OF APPROACH???



On the other hand they kick co-researchers in the nuts who are doing similar
things with metals and hydrides, drag them DOWN INTO THE MIRE BY ASSOCIATION
when all that needed to be said was:

"We get excess heat, we don't know what the mechanism is but there is
definitely excess heat"


Charismatic mono-idea-its who never touch reality are soggy floating turds
in the punch bowl of serious endeavour. (Does a soggy turd float? On the
stock market I guess)

Yes, having an intuition may guide you to the result (or even completely
different directions) even if the intuition is wrong. But it must touch
reality to be called Science.

The CF, LENR people I'd call the Anomalous Metal Hydride Excess Heat
Phenomena (AMHEHP?) and start again. Get the best (**experimenters**) in the
field and keep the cranks out unless they come to you with something that
works. They'll drag you down and kill it all.

You go in with the CERTAINTY of what something IS by giving it a NAME. If
research is open-ended you might not know what that thing even is. 

Changing CF to LENR was a good move. Besides some programming language has
appropriated the name.

Changing Global Warming to Climate Change is a similar move because some
prediction from xs CO2 cause a cooling, ironically, by altering airflow or
ocean current flow.

Sorry bedtime the clocks have gone back. 

-----Original Message-----
From: Robin van Spaandonk [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Sent: 26 October 2008 21:55
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [Vo]:NaH - strong and strange

In reply to  Remi Cornwall's message of Sun, 26 Oct 2008 21:42:34 -0000:
Hi Remi,
[snip]
>Have you ever come across Hydrinos?
>
> 
>
>Can people tell the difference between Star Trek and the Discovery channel?
>
> 
>
>Despite the Arthur C Clarke quote, the initiated know the difference
between
>science, the pursuit of science and pure and applied bullshitology.
[snip]
Nobody knows anything. There is no such thing as knowledge, because
knowledge
implies certainty, and there is always some element of doubt.

Regards,

Robin van Spaandonk <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>



Reply via email to