Edmund Storms wrote:

Of course, CF could help. However, at least 10 years will be required to master CF and introduce it at high level into the energy system. The present system contains enormous financial and infrastructure inertia that prevents adding energy from any source very fast. I'm predicting that we will not be able to respond fast enough.

I agree that we may not respond fast enough. It is likely we will not. But not for lack of ability. We could respond if we had the willpower. People have acted quickly in the past, in similar situations. Or they have failed to act, and their civilizations have collapsed and vanished; see J. Diamond, "Collapse."

I have often quoted Freeman Dyson on this subject:

". . . [The] experiences of World War II made an indelible impression on people of my generation. At the bottom of our hearts we still believe you can have anything you want in five years if you need it badly enough and if you are prepared to slog your way through the barriers of confusion and incompetence to get it. . . . The accepted wisdom says that, no matter what we decide to do about economic problems, we cannot expect to see any substantial results [for 15 years]. The accepted wisdom is no doubt correct, if we continue to play the game by the rules of today. But anyone who lived through World War II knows that the rules can be changed very fast when the necessity arises."

The U.S. has accomplished astounding feats in a short time in response to crisis, in the Civil War, the Great Depression and WWII. You might predict that we cannot do that again, but I wouldn't be so sure. Never sell Americans short. As Winston Churchill said: "Americans can always be counted on to do the right thing...after they have exhausted all other possibilities."

We did not seem competent or prepared at the outset of those previous crises, but we managed, to a large extent because we selected Lincoln and FDR as our leader, and they were among the best in the history of the world. I do not normally subscribe to the "great man" school of history, but it is difficult to imagine haw we would have survived without them. Of course there would still be a United States, but it would be a crabbed, divided, un-free place, and Europe would be ruled by the descendants of the Nazis.

- Jed

Reply via email to