>From Horace:

> http://www.worldnpa.org/php2/index.php?
> tab0=Experiments&tab1=Display&id=5
>
> http://tinyurl.com/orcekf
>
> Has anyone here actually done a similar *experiment*?
>
> Simulation programs are useless in this regard.

Indeed, simulation programs often leave much to be desired. I would
never "bet the farm" on a computer simulation alone. However, it seems
to me that Hoyt describes an accurate explanation for this effect when
he followed-up with:

> It's just that you're pushing the BH curve down with H
> so the field strength B is lower in repulsion. Remember these
> are highly non-linear materials.

The pushing of the BH curve into the interior of the PM when two like
poles are pushed closer together is quite evident graphically speaking
when performing FEMM simulations. I noticed this effect all the time
in my FEMM simulations. The result invariably is that repulsive forces
seem to be weaker as compared to the associated attractive forces,
when two opposite poles are placed at the same physical distance from
each other.

To recap, it seems to me that Hoyt's comment easily explains the
graphic as displayed out at:

http://tinyurl.com/orcekf

I'm sure the experiment describes an accurate observation of Mother
Nature's forces. Nevertheless, I'm puzzled that this particular
experiment is making such a big deal out of the phenomenon.

Please understand. I'm not claiming there IS no OU and/or asymmetry in
certain PM configurations. I have insufficient knowledge on the matter
to proclaim such an absurd conclusion.

Regards
Steven Vincent Johnson
www.OrionWorks.com
www.zazzle.com/orionworks

Reply via email to