Mary Yugo asked me, how do we know for sure that any of this information
provided by Rossi on Oct. 28 is real? "None of the invited scientists and
press people had any access to any sort of meters or measuring devices" She
has a valid point. As I said here, we do not know for sure. The Oct. 6 test
produced objective, first-principle scientific proof that cannot be faked,
but this test did not. Here is my response to Yugo:

The measurements were not made by Rossi. They were made by a team of five
HVAC engineers led by Domenico Fioravanti. I do not know who Fioravanti is,
but reporters researchers at the test say he is in his 60s and he and the
others are highly experienced professionals. There reporters and
researchers are themselves knowledgeable and could not be fooled by an
amateur pretending to be an engineer.

It is possible that Rossi hired these people and had them use false names
to conduct an elaborate hoax. But I do not think that is likely because:

1. I do not believe in conspiracy theories. This is real life, not a James
Bond movie.

2. It would cost hundreds of thousands of dollars to set up this equipment,
even if it is fake, and I do not think Rossi has that kind of money.

3. I do not see how it could pay off. The deception is bound to be revealed
soon.

4. There is no doubt that Fioravanti and the others are engineers. I think
it is extremely unlikely that Rossi could persuade such people to go along
with a hoax. The deception will certainly be revealed; they will be found
out; their professional licenses will be revoked, their careers destroyed,
and they will face criminal charges. I do not think the Rossi can afford to
pay five people to destroy their own lives in order to prolong a fraud for
a few extra weeks.

To summarize, we do not know *for sure* that Fioravanti is who he says he
is, but it seems unlikely to me that he is not. That would call for an
elaborate, expensive and utterly pointless hoax. It calls for many
middle-aged people willing to destroy their lives for no reason. Even if
they are not actually HVAC engineers they will face criminal charges for
fraud. Maybe Rossi could get unknown college-age kids to engage in a prank
of this nature, but not professionals who will lose their jobs, spend years
defending themselves in court at ruinous expense, and end up working a
minimum wage job in their retirement years.

There is no chance Fioravanti is an actor who fooled the professors, the AP
guy, Lewan and others. It is conceivable that all of these people together,
Levi, Lewan and the AP guy, are engaged in a gigantic fraud to fool the
outside world, but that is even more improbable.

- Jed

Reply via email to