You seem to believe that Rossi owes you an explanation. He dislikes you intenslyas a member of the chattering class and will not be affected by your demands for proof.
Rossi will cooperate with his cu stomers up to a point. He will remove the veil from his invention just enough to get a customer to buy this thing. That is how our world works, money for information…it is as simple as that. If you think he is scamming, you are free to withhold your money. You seem to want something for nothing…which just does not happen in this life. On Mon, Nov 14, 2011 at 2:04 PM, Mary Yugo <maryyu...@gmail.com> wrote: > All of the doubts are from the peanut gallery on the Internet, >> especially people such as Mary Yugo. She says she knows nothing about cold >> fusion, so obviously she cannot judge. Asking her to evaluate this would be >> like asking me to review a performance of the Metropolitan Opera. I do not >> know the first thing about music and I have never listened to the >> Metropolitan Opera. So I am not qualified to critique them. I doubt anyone >> would argue with that. I cannot imagine why anyone takes Yugo or Park >> seriously, when they brag they have not even bothered to read the >> fundamentals, and they make many silly factual mistakes. >> > > It is not necessary to know anything whatever about cold fusion to > evaluate Rossi's claims and the performance of his machine. I have no idea > why you persist in missing that point. That some other people may have > discovered cold fusion is almost entirely irrelevant to Rossi's extravagant > claim of megawatt power levels. Rossi's claim is very easy to prove. You > yourself have told him how to do it unequivocally many times and he has > completely ignored your suggestions and has not asked any of your suggested > experts to test it for him. And that tells you nothing? > > As it happens, I understand the basics of heat transfer and fluid flow and > have been involved professionally in the design of Seebeck effect > calorimeters. I am entirely capable of determining if Rossi has properly > tested his machines and has presented proper evidence. I don't need to > study a single thing about cold fusion to do it. Testing Rossi's machines > requires no knowledge of cold fusion. They need to be tested as a black > box, purporting to be a net, long lasting, efficient source of excess > energy. Until that's done, I couldn't give an invisible unicorn to find > out *how* he does it. > > Before you determine how Rossi makes lots of excess energy, it's essential > to prove that he does. That has not been done properly, adequately and > independently. That fact has absolutely nothing whatever to do with cold > fusion. It has everything to do with Rossi's intransigence and resistance > to proper independent tests. My working theory on why he behaves that way > is that he's scamming. He can easily falsify the premise for us by > providing independent tests or even a credible, reliable client who will > vouch for him. He has not done that so the matter remains unknown. > > >
