While I don't think Stirling are good for larger sizes I do think that they
might work well for 0.2-3kW.  Stirling engines were in large volume
production 100 years ago for small output applications (though they were
big and heavy), and the cost is less of a negative factor for small sizes
if they work well and can run for 10's of thousands of hours (which some
low output stirling engines like Infinia, Microgen and Whispergen can).
 While at the moment those engines still cost $2-3000 per kW and are very
heavy (10's of kg per kW), the cost might come down by a factor of 3 or
more in mass production, and they do have good efficiency of up to 30%.

Steam engines will be very strong competition, It's amazing how small and
powerful they are (competitive with IC engines).  Check out cyclone power
http://www.cyclonepower.com/ to see how good they might be (claiming 150kg,
75kW, and up to 30% efficient from a 6 cylinder radial steam engine
integrated with heater and condenser). But steam is also very dangerous in
a crash, and their might be reliability/life issues.  I don't think I would
want to ride a motorbike with steam storage between my legs, and might also
be a bit concerned with it in a car.

On 8 February 2012 20:03, Alain Sepeda <[email protected]> wrote:

> from discussion here I got the feeling that at a given minimum size,
> the answer is  : Rankine Cycle turbine, maybe Organic Rankine.
> however the minimum size is not clear...
> maybe car (20-50kW) is possible.
> have to work on turbine, but also radiators, key problem.
>
> for CHP 7-15KW, not sure it can be efficient, but it works.
>
>
> for smaller power, or smaller vehicle (motor bikes, moped, bike assist)...
> maybe no good solution.
> stirling or turbines are too heavy, have low efficiency.
> thermoelectric devices have bad efficiency
>
> for bikeassist less that 100W mecanic , with a battery, in serial hybrid
> configuration, could do the job (to refill in the day/night, and push on
> slope about 200-500W).
> miniaturization will be more important than efficiency.
> for moped you can get 1-2kW...
> for motorbike it can start from few 5kW to above 50kW, but won't be fun
> over 10-20kW unlike today
>
>
> 2012/2/8 Guenter Wildgruber <[email protected]>
>
>>  The next billion dollar question: How to get electricity from say 400°C
>> with minimal cost/maximum efficiency?
>>
>
>

Reply via email to