Dear Abd, Thank for writing here, this opens ways to a good discussion, not focused on minor details.
I think what we have in common and motivates both of us is the care for the future of the LENR field. As regarding in which extent I agree with you, it is very exactly 50%. You say: *"At this point, we need more science and pure scientific investigation (controlled experiment), and, arguably, less attempt to scale up and "make it more reliable." * * * I agree with the first part, but not with the second. I think both approaches are necessary and complete each other. Why are both approaches necessary? Till now LENR has been developed in conditions of chronic scarcity, scarcity of funds, of attention and of empathy. The Rossi series of experiments performed with much mass media tam-tam have radically improved the acceptance or at least the taking in consideration of LENR. Commercial development has to continue and the first commercial LENR will bring a real change of attitude. Interestingly enough, surprisingly this process was generated and has been developed outside the LENR community. The 2.10 exp 12 cents question is- starting from the achievements and knowledge of the LENR community will it be possible to obtain a real energy source? My guess is that your favorite is the SCIENCE FIRST part. Indeed the human mission is to understand, to know to explain and to use knowledge in practice. However, is this possible, for Pd-D systems, for transition metals-H systems with nanopowders and for the new, Rossi\ and Defkalion systems? Let's try to do serious scientific research for the Pd-D system- as you wish. Just a remark here- it always were two trends in classical cold fusion LENR: a) to obtain more reliable results at higher intensities of heat release; b) to use more- much more sensitive methods of measurement- very good calorimetric methods Can we say that the 3 inborn weaknesses of Pd-D have been eliminated and we have a system we can use for Science? I am speaking not only about bad reproducibility it is a bad combination of low intensity, unreliability and ephemerity. Which is the source of solid data you can build science upon? Which results from our great past will be usable here? With no difference and no contradiction to/with other results also from our great past? See please a recent example it says 20 % success rate: http://mizzouweekly.missouri.edu/archive/2012/33-28/reactor/index.php. Excellent group in an elite lab. Can we speak about a controlled experiment? It is better to discuss how to organize a series of experiments that can give scientific results? How to take responsibility and who will take it? I am not very confident in the real possibilities to do serious science with Pd-D LENR. You well know that I think that all these systems are actually poisoned - the gases from air compete with deuterium on the cative sites, or NAE if you wish. With your permission re theories and the newer LENR systems I willa nswer you on my blog. Peter * * On Wed, May 2, 2012 at 4:16 AM, Abd ul-Rahman Lomax <[email protected]>wrote: > I responded, "anonymously," but it should be pretty obvious it was me .... > I've been harping on the same theme for months now. > > At this point, we need more science and pure scientific investigation > (controlled experiment), and, arguably, less attempt to scale up and "make > it more reliable." Cold fusion, and specifically the FPHE, is already > reliable enough to do the needed research, through the power of correlation. > > Characterizing the reactions or results that have already been found, and > especially those replicated in some way, should have taken priority from > 1989 on, instead what we got, and endless and largely fruitless quest to > satisfy pseudoskeptics who wanted BIG, PUNCH-ME-IN-THE-NOSE results, before > condescending to look at the actual science, at what can be known from what > is already observed and properly documented and reported. > > Once the helium correlation with excess heat was discovered, and > especially once it was confirmed, the "reality" of cold fusion should have > been a closed chapter in this history. (Unless manages to demonstrate > artifact in the *correlation.* I have seen no proposed theory of artifact > that is at all consistent with experimental results, far less an actual > demonstration that tests such a theory.) > > Is it truly cold and is it truly fusion? Well, it's got to be nuclear in > nature, but until we know what it *is* -- and we don't -- we can't rule > anything out, not completely. > > As it is, we largely have a pile of results, from which little that is > truly solid can be deduced, because conditions have not been controlled > across protocols, which multiplied like rabbits. Bockris reported tritium. > Great. What was the hydrogen/deuterium ratio in his heavy water, and how > was it known, and how did that compare with his tritium and excess heat > results? He also measured helium, as I recall. How did helium compare with > tritium and the other results and experimental variables? > > Miles also tested for tritium. He doesn't usually report the values > *because they were too low for tritium to be the product of the main > heat-producing reaction.* And that's what people wanted to know, what was > "the" ash? Every piece of correlated information about the behavior of > Fleischmann-Pons cells is valuable, including behavior when there is no > heat, especially if the conditions *appear* to be the same. > > One of the criticisms of cold fusion work is that reported results have > been cherry-picked. It's true for some research groups, not for others. > Further, results considered significant for the "nuclear" issue are > reported, too often in complete isolation from other results, in the same > experimental series or even with the same cell. The result is an > inefficient mish-mosh. And piles of "amazing" results that nobody attempts > to replicate. There are few exceptions, I can think of McKubre replicating > Energetics Technologies' SuperWave approach. ENEA also worked on that, but, > apparently unlike McKubre, did not report all cells, only the ones with > apparent excess heat, which, absent information about the "duds," really > tells us much less than a full report. > > It's time that the cold fusion wake up and take responsibility for the > situation. It's time to stop blaming the physicists for lack of funding. > It's time to start using the resources we have, and using them well and > effectively and efficiently. It's going to take cooperation. > > Or, I suppose, we can muddle along, bickering about whose theory is > better, and hope that Saint Rossi rescues us, by delivering > impossible-to-dismiss results that you can buy at Home Depot. > > As far as I can tell, though, what Rossi has found/exaggerated/faked, or > whatever it is, is not the same reaction as with the Fleischmann-Pons Heat > Effect, it isn't the same catalyst or catalytic context, and it may or may > not involve some similar mechanism. If Rossi's approach works, it brings > us, by itself, no closer to understanding LENR, indeed, it seems to deepen > the mystery. > > And since Rossi's work is secret, without clearly disclosed results and > controlled experiment, we cannot sensibly suspend our work and study based > on some idea that he's going to make it all useless next month -- or next > year. No, the FPHE (excess heat through loading palladium with deuterium > using electrolysis) remains an accessible way to set up and observe and > measure LENR. It will likely never be practical for power generation. So > what? > > What we can learn by studying it may enable engineering of new effects > that may turn into practical applications. And, sure, that might involve > nickel and hydrogen. Storms is claiming that the NAE is cracks, and that > the same NAE can fuse hydrogen with itself, hydrogen with deuterium, and > deuterium with deuterium, through electron catalysis or involvement (the > involvement is necessary for pure hydrogen fusion, which then makes > deuterium). > > But none of this is established except the conversion of deuterium to > helium, with the number of deuterium nuclei or atoms involved in the > reaction being unknown, all we know is that the helium is produced with > roughly the right value for deuterium fusion to helium with *any mechanism* > that starts with that fuel and ends with that ash. > > (Has anyone seen alleged nuclear product from Ni-H that was correlated > with anomalous heat? Wouldn't that be interesting?) > > (Rossi actively dismissed the very idea of controls, why should he bother > with a control, since he believes he knows what happens with the control, > i.e., nothing. Except that "nothing" is not what happens. What a control > might do is show how much steam the same input power would generate, which > isn't "nothing." It's less or a lot less or it's a certain temperature > reached, not "nothing." Or it's the same, and not running a control allows > no verification of Rossi's expectation. A control is almost useless, > though, if it is not possible to verify that the control is identical to > the experimental cell except for the variable.) > > > At 09:45 AM 5/1/2012, you wrote: > >> My dear friends, >> I have sinned again, this time it is about more capital sins. >> See please: >> <http://egooutpeters.blogspot.**com/2012/05/detailitis-kills-** >> discussion-in-lenr-too.html<http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com/2012/05/detailitis-kills-discussion-in-lenr-too.html> >> >ht**tp://egooutpeters.blogspot.**com/2012/05/detailitis-kills-** >> discussion-in-lenr-too.html<http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com/2012/05/detailitis-kills-discussion-in-lenr-too.html> >> >> Best wishes to you all, >> Peter >> -- >> Dr. Peter Gluck >> Cluj, Romania >> <http://egooutpeters.blogspot.**com <http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com>> >> http://egooutpeters.**blogspot.com <http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com> >> > > -- Dr. Peter Gluck Cluj, Romania http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com

