Hi Ron,

 

This is surprisingly amateurish abstract, to be coming from phys.org. but I
guess they do not have an inclination to be more precise in a what amounts
to a PR writeup for an article they sell for more than Amazon charges for a
novel. 

 

EEs have long suspected that some physicists have a shallow understanding of
"electricity" at a basic working level, and this article will probably do
little to change that perception. As Bill B sez: ELECTRICITY DOES NOT EXIST
as a general phenomenon which is free of contradiction, so if you chose any
partial POV and neglect the others - you can make something look wrong. 

 

The writer, Liz Ahlberg is essentially using the grade-school understanding
of "electricity" as her straw man, so sure - that one is easy to shoot it
down.

 

There is a whole world out there for understanding other forms of
conductivity, which the writer, or more likely Phillips, the principle
researcher - apparently chooses to neglect at least in this promo piece. 

 

"Phonon-assisted conductivity" goes back at least a decade, and that would
appear to be what is being overlooked here. But since they want you to pay a
hefty fee for simply reading the article, I may never know. 

 

A cynic would complain that this is a counter-productive trend in science
publishing - that approaches a sophisticated form of robbery .:-) . 

 

 

From: Ron Kita 

 

Greetings Vortex,

 

http://phys.org/news/2013-03-electrons-cuprate-superconductors-defy-conventi
on.html

 

Respectfully,

Ron Kita, Chiralex

Reply via email to