Of these cells, how many of them were in a mode where the heat production was unequivocal in the sense that a casual observer would be hard pressed to deny what was going on?
Good examples of this in history are the: 1) original "hole in the lab table" event that triggered F&P to pursue the phenomenon in earnest 2) the original "heat after death" event that boiled away the D2O without any energy input? On Wed, Mar 12, 2014 at 5:25 PM, Kevin O'Malley <kevmol...@gmail.com> wrote: > Then it is easy to see how someone like JT He who reviewed the evidence > could come up with 14000 replications. > > Let's say that, using Ed's figure of 1060 reports, that an average of 14 > cells were successful for each experiment. That would get you the 14000 > figure very quickly. And I've seen indications that some of these guys > were getting more than a hundred cells to work. > > > On Wed, Mar 12, 2014 at 2:54 PM, Jed Rothwell <jedrothw...@gmail.com>wrote: > >> Kevin O'Malley <kevmol...@gmail.com> wrote: >> >> I see it all over the place that "hundreds of times" it's been >>> successfully replicated. Here, Storms says: "During the 20 years since >>> the original claim, hundreds of successful replications have been >>> published." He then goes on to look at 386 of them. >>> >>> >>> http://fusiontorch.com/uploads/StormsJudgingValidityOfFleischmannPonsEffect2009.pdf >>> >> >> >> Let me point out that this is 386 reports, or laboratories reporting. >> There are many more individual experimental runs than this. >> >> This paper references Storms' book, and the tables in it. It has a list, >> "Reported successful FPE experiments" which begins: >> >> "Excess Heat, Table 2, pages 53-61, Number of Successes 184 >> Tritium Production Table 6, pages 79-81, Number of Successes 61 >> . . ." >> >> In the book, the first thing listed in Table 2 is: >> >> "Dardik et al. DW Iso. open electrolytic Pd, LiOD+, D2O, 1.8" >> >> Dardik has done hundreds of positive experiments by now. So have some of >> the other groups in the list of 184 positive excess heat experiments. >> >> - Jed >> >> >
