Re: [Vo]:Say it ain't so, Joe -- Peer Review

[Alan Fletcher]

***Perhaps you are not familiar with Rossi's 
credibility issues regarding his past posts on JONP.Â

Contrariwise, almost everything he's referred to 
has come to fruition in one form or another. 
(Maybe not the automated factory, but where DID 
all those 1MW units, in 3 different models, come from?)

***Yes, there are.  I just find it difficult 
to believe that these 7 PhD's are so 
incompetent.  I mean, the vast majority of 
Vorts knew that there would probably have to be 
 isotopic analysis on the 6 month test.  But 
these geniuses are ONLY NOW getting around to 
thinking about doing it?  That simply does not add up.Â

The test has only just ended. I just hope they 
had enough sample material to do multiple tests. 
That's the one aspect that could be done 
differently if the reviewers suggest/require it.

And I repeat my wish that they'd separate the 
calorimetric and mass spectrometry papers.