I wrote:

> Jones Beene <jone...@pacbell.net> wrote:
>
>
>> Geeze you are sounding almost as bad as Levi - in not seeing the obvious
>> ... “about the same” is absurd, given what happens later. The difference
>> between 486 and 790 is enormous when the delta-T is being raised by a
>> formula which includes a fourth power (Stefan–Boltzmann law)
>>
>
> The temperature was also measured with a thermocouple, as noted.
>

Ah, but your point is that even if the the temperature is measured
correctly, may not reflect the power correctly.

That would be a rewrite of the textbooks. In any case, a temperature
calibration curve goes down, not up, at higher power levels.

At 486 W the temperature was 437°C. At 786 W it went up to 1240°C. No
matter how you look at it, it should have been reasonably proportional, and
no higher than ~750°C. Unless they were pouring ice water on the thing
during calibration, or a blast from a fan, there is no way it could go so
much higher with only 1.6 times more power.

(Those numbers are Tables 3, 6 and 7.)

- Jed

Reply via email to