Alan Burlison wrote:
> You'll only have to log in if you want to change anything, which immediately 
> excludes most casual users.
>>> although this will of course be configurable. 
>> As long as it can be set to things like "2 weeks", "1 month" or even 
>> "never"...
> 
> It will most probably be a small number of hours, and certainly not more 
> than a day.
> 

I think that this misses the point -  when I access the site once or
twice a week, I do so to edit web pages and the like.  This policy limit
(which seems overly restrictive to me) means that statistically, *every* 
time community leaders like myself access the site to update page content, 
they will be forced to relogin, making the remember-me feature almost
completely worthless to the very community leaders for whom it was 
designed.

Given that the current "4 years and counting" scheme hasn't exposed any 
documented (or even alleged) instances of cookie theft and/or unauthorized
alterations, and lacking any data to back up your preference for "between 
one and four hours", I'd like to suggest that the predominant use-case 
(not to mention industry-wide norms) calls for a 2-week period instead.

  -John
_______________________________________________
website-discuss mailing list
[email protected]

Reply via email to