On Tue, 29 Aug 2006 22:55:01 +0100, Matthew Raymond <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

Having data table representing list of items where large clickable area is useful - i.e. inbox in a webmail, list of contacts, forum threads listing, etc.

I've ran into this problem many times and seen many questions about this
on forums/usenet.

My current solution is:
<tr onclick="this.getElementsByTagName('a')[0].click()">

   This can be accomplished by having <a> elements in each individual
cell...

Ofcourse it can, but it bloats code a lot. You have to add several redundant links, add tabindex=-1 to avoid breaking keyboard navigation, move all table and cell styles to anchors, and if cells contain block elements you have to bloat your code even more.

Another situation where I wanted href on any element was advertisement:

<div href="/buy">
<p>My product is:</p>
<ul>
<li>Cool</li>
<li>Great</li>
<li>And soo semantic</li>
</ul>
</div>

   People don't typically don't initiate a purchase in a user interface
by clicking on the product description.

Make it href="/info" then. Sometimes it doesn't make sense to have separate page for each listed detail.


Ofcourse you can live without href on every element if you apply a bit of scripting and CSS tricks, but the same thing can be said about almost every thing in WHATWG specifications.


It can have some backwards-compatibility. AFAIK XHTML/2 allows nested anchors, so I'd use it like this:

<tr href=".."><td><a href="..">anchor</a></td><td>no anchor</td><td>no anchor</td><td>no anchor</td></tr>

With some scripting (see first code in this post) this could work in current browsers and had fallback for bots and non-JS agents.

--
regards, Kornel LesiƄski

Reply via email to