Here's a page I constructed, and tested on Firefox:

http://intertwingly.net/stories/2007/04/10/test.html

This page is meant to be served as application/xhtml+xml.

Can you test it and see what results you get?  Then lets discuss further.

In Safari 2.0.4: Processed as HTML, it says "data" and then "". Processed as XHTML, it says "null" and then "data". In Opera 9.00: Processed as HTML, it says "data" and then "null". Processed as XHTML, it says "null" and then "data". In Firefox 2.0.0.3: Processed as HTML, it says "data" and then "". Processed as XHTML, it says "data" and then "data". In IE/Mac 5.2: Processed as HTML, it says "data" and the second alert does not appear. Processed as XHTML, neither alert appears.

It looks like Firefox's XHTML implementation already has the getAttribute extension I suggested of handling QNames.

Firefox is AFAICT the one following spec here. The spec says that getAttribute in a namespaced document should return the node with the given qname.

Though I thought we returned null when getAttributeNS failed, but it appears we only do that for getAttribute.

/ Jonas

Reply via email to