On Feb 8, 2013, at 7:18 AM, Antoine Musso <hashar+...@free.fr> wrote:
> A) http://doc.wikimedia.org/mediawiki-core/<branch|tag>/php > > Would bring: > > doc.wikimedia.org/mediawiki-core/master/php > doc.wikimedia.org/mediawiki-core/master/js > doc.wikimedia.org/mediawiki-core/1.20.2/php > doc.wikimedia.org/mediawiki-core/REL1_20/js > doc.wikimedia.org/mediawiki-AbuseFilter/1.20.2/php > > > B) doc.mediawiki.org/<project>/<type>/<version>/ > > Would bring: > > doc.mediawiki.org/core/php/master > doc.mediawiki.org/core/js/master > doc.mediawiki.org/core/php/1.20.2 > doc.mediawiki.org/core/js/REL1_20 > doc.mediawiki.org/AbuseFilter/php/REL1_20 > > I would prefer having the MediaWiki doc hosted on the mediawiki.org > domain. As for the ordering I guess we can bikeshed for a long time but > most probably some ordering will seem natural for most people there :-] > > Thanks! > Presenting them as A and B seems flawed as they are separate things: Let's decouple them into a matrix of more tangible decisions: A) Do we want to maintain two domain names for our documentation? No, * We already have doc.wikimedia.org, doc.mediawiki.org would be a new one * If we maintain separate domain names, when is something "mediawiki" and when is it "wikimedia"? For example, documentation for jQuery plugins, VisualEditor etc are stand alone, most certainly not MediaWiki specific. There is no reason to force ourselves into this ambiguity. One domain is all we need. With some redirects perhaps. B) Hierarchy of directories project, branch and category of code (usually a programming language). 6 possible combinations of these 3. *The one I've proposed before and rationalised in the comment thread is project > branch > code-category. * This because not all projects have the same code categories. A tree is usually structured towards more specificity down the tree. * With the separator of time as high up as possible so that you don't duplicate versions in multiple locations. * Easier to maintain if we rename the code categories later on. * Easier to generate to have everything go in 1 target directory and not separate directories in different locations. I appreciate you putting thought into these minor details, but I think this discussion is pointless because you're not providing any rational input yourself (all I see it "I prefer" which is undeniably a useless argument to defend against). I can talk for hours, but it help get the documentation deployed if you don't communicate. The thread can become slightly more useful if you had actually provided some arguments of your own. I've explained the reasons for my version, then you reverted it with no explanation, linking[1] only to this post on wikitech-l, where you merely present A and B once again with no explanation as to why you disagree in the first place. I'd love to discuss the advantage of your version or disadvantage of mine, preferably as a simple response to my question in Gerrit, but here is fine too. Let's keep in mind the bigger picture and do what's best for the users. On Feb 8, 2013, at 7:41 AM, bawolff <bawolff...@gmail.com> wrote: > Whichever way we chose, could we have http redirects from the old > svn.wikimedia.org? There's a lot of urls that link there. > Unrelated. Yes, of course. When we move it, the old location will become a redirect. > I prefer doc.mediawiki.org/<project>/<version>/<master> (aka > doc.mediawiki.org/core/master/php ) as in my mind, the hierarchy makes > more sense like that, as the type of code is something more > fine-grained than what version, and also something that belongs to the > version number in a sense. I also like keeping the names MediaWiki and > Wikimedia separate. At the end of the day it doesn't really matter > which way though. > I agree. > It would also be cool if puppet docs were on doc.wikimedia.org, but if > you had doc.mediawiki.org in the url, things auto redirected (and vice > veras: if you went to doc.wikimedia.org/core/master/php things > redirected to doc.mediawiki.org/core/master/php ) > I'm not sure we should be maintaining two domains. We can have doc.mediawiki.org redirect to doc.wikimedia.org/mediawiki-core, but to maintain both would be confusing, decentralising and depending on the implementation, it would encourage using multiple urls for the same thing. Might as well stick with one canonical url. Best, -- Krinkle [1] https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/39212 _______________________________________________ Wikitech-l mailing list Wikitech-l@lists.wikimedia.org https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikitech-l
