Re: GIT rebase changes

[Eric POUECH]

why don't you guys use stg (stacked git)

it allows you to manage a set of patches, with features like :

- re-edit an existing one (basically, you push/pull a set of patches from a stack, and decide which one to use)

- you get the upside of git, without the down side (ie a commit is done only once) (but you can still commit a patch - in git sense ; but you'll get back Mike's first point about pull/fetch discussion)

- you don't need to rebase (it does it for you)

- you don't need to coalesce patches (as you can reedit an existing one)

- it's compatible with some other tools (like qgit)

basically, I switched to stg - on top of git - when I got my tree messed up twice by updates...

If you go for stg, I also recommend the bash completion extension which is very helpful (for patch name's management)

my 2 cents

> Message du 18/01/06 17:39
> De : "Robert Shearman" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> A : "Mike McCormack" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> Copie à : "Wine Devel"
> Objet : Re: GIT rebase changes
>
> Mike McCormack wrote:
>
> >
> > Hi GIT users,
> >
> > The GIT guys have made rebase and pull incompatible, and to use rebase
> > (which is likely what we want to do for Wine), you must use "fetch"
> > then "rebase", not "pull" (which does a merge).
>
>
> And on a slightly related note, I wrote a script which works kinda like
> rebase (and is based on the old version of rebase) that allows you to
> coalesce two patches in your tree. This is useful in two situations:
> 1. You commit a new feature and then realise after some extensive
> testing that there is a bug, so you commit a fix, don't want to send the
> two separate patches to wine-patches (maybe to save face :-), or maybe
> to reduce noise).
> 2. You revert a patch in your tree but don't want both the revert and
> the old patch in your patch queue as shown by git-format-patch or by
> Mike's mm-send-patch.
>
> Note that the first commit chronologically must be the first commit on
> the command line.
>
> --
> Rob Shearman
>
> >
> [ rob-git-coalesce-patches (2.5 Ko) ]
> [ (pas de nom de fichier) (0.0 Ko) ]