On May 12, 2013, at 1:12 PM, Ken Thomases wrote: > I'm not seeing that problem happen here. Mind you, I'm currently testing on > 10.6. I'll have to run some tests on 10.7+ tomorrow. > > I find it improbable that removing NSResizableWindowMask from the style > doesn't disable the zoom button. That style is the only thing which enables > the zoom button to begin with. In other words, in a normal Mac app, one > would not need to disable the zoom button separately. >
Looks like you sent a patch for this. The title is also empty when exiting borderless to titled, which can be fixed here. > Also, if the Windows program changes a window from resizable to > non-resizable, then we should probably pull the window out of Cocoa > fullscreen. The Windows program _may_ have intended to make the window > full-screen but we can't know that. It may simply be changing the window > style for some other purpose, and that may make it no longer a candidate for > Cocoa full-screen mode. > Allowing Windows fullscreen in Cocoa fullscreen was never a very good idea. I did not want to force the window out, but a borderless window would not be allowed to enter Cocoa fullscreen, so it probably should not be there. > I disagree. Windows programs that are not expecting their window to resize > (because they haven't made them resizable) can misbehave badly if the window > does resize. Just because that didn't happen in your testing doesn't mean it > won't. > > As you mentioned in your original email, Cocoa full-screen is roughly akin to > window resizing. So, it should be disabled if/when the window is made > non-resizable. > I do not see the reason to disable buttons and make the windows non-resizable. Probably wrong here, but doesn't this just eliminate click-through, which is typical of Windows apps, because the Windows paradigm stinks? > I don't follow this. It is possible to resize any window even non-resizable > ones? To what are you referring? Possible how? Do you mean specifically > just with this full-screen patch? > It is possible to do anything we want with a window. The actual Windows program not freaking out is another story. Just pointing out that we are not limited.
