XBL 2.0 HTML disposition of comments script

Wed, 22 Nov 2006 12:08:32 -0800

At the moment it causes a small amount of dataloss and has some other small issues. But hey: it does generate HTML. Patches accepted! 

--
Anne van Kesteren
<http://annevankesteren.nl/>
<http://www.opera.com/>


Attachment:
disposition-of-comments2html.py

Description: Binary data


Title: XBL 2.0 Disposition of Comments



 
 
  
XBL 2.0 Disposition of Comments

  
Comment 1

  
Summary: Request for more examples.

  
Status: Agreed.

  
  
Comment 2

  
Summary: Typos in examples.

  
Status: Agreed.

  
  
Comment 3

  
Summary: Issues with namespace prefixes in selectors

  
Status: Disagreed with proposal of introducing new prefix declaration

  
    
  

  
Comment 4

  
Summary: Query regarding requirements for authoring tools

  
Status: Resolved as part of comment 11.

  
  
Comment 5

  
Summary: Use "fragment body" instead of "subtree" when definining "XBL subtree".

  
Status: Rejected on technical grounds.

  
  
Comment 6

  
Summary: Suggestions for a better abstract.

  
Status: Made some changes, though not all those suggested.

  
  
Comment 7

  
Summary: Suggestions for a better introduction.

  
Status: Rejected; the suggestions did not seem like improvements.

  
  
Comment 8

  
Summary: Comments regarding extensibility.

  
Status: Made some changes, though not all those suggested.

  
  
Comment 9

  
Summary: Comment regarding xml:id and request to get review from XMLCWG

  

  
    
  

  
Comment 10

  
Summary: Confusion about the definition of "shadow tree".

  
Status: Unclear how to proceed. Rejected pending further comment.

  
  
Comment 11

  
Summary: Request to define conformance classes.

  
Status: Accepted.

  
  
Comment 12

  
Summary: Request to define "expected context" and to use a schema language.

  
Status: Fixed text to avoid needing to define the term. Couldn't find

  
    
  

  
Comment 13

  
Summary: Request to change some element names.

  
Status: Rejected since current names were the result of a lot of time

  
    
  

  
Comment 14

  
Summary: Request to allow any implementation mechanism for parsing.

  
Status: Reviewer said the issue was on hold. Unclear how to proceed.

  
  
Comment 15

  
Summary: Request to split a paragraph in two.

  
Status: Agreed. Fixed that paragraph and a number of other ones.

  
  
Comment 16

  
Summary: Query about the "unless it has already been loaded" text.

  
Status: Query was based on misunderstanding. Clarified spec a little.

  
  
Comment 17

  
Summary: Comment regarding XML Events and request to work with HTMLWG

  
Status: Unclear how to proceed. Rejected pending further comment.

  
  
Comment 18

  
Summary: Suggestion not to use @namespace url() syntax.

  
Status: Rejected. Reviewer said the issue was on hold. Unclear how to

  
    
  

  
Comment 19

  
Summary: Question about the term "semantic-free XML element".

  
Status: Unclear how to proceed. Rejected pending further comment.

  
  
Comment 20

  
Summary: Request to clarify "do not support CSS".

  
Status: Rejected.

  
  
Comment 21

  
Summary: Editorial fix in xblSetInsertionPoint definition.

  
Status: Fixed.

  
  
Comment 22

  
Summary: are interfaces always implemented?

  
Status: Fixed.

  
  
Comment 23

  
Summary: Abstract changes.

  
Status: Fixed.

  
  
Comment 24

  
Summary: Confusion over the word "ignore"

  
Status: Fixed.

  
 














    











					Reply via email to