http://nagoya.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=2508 *** shadow/2508 Sun Jul 8 19:26:16 2001 --- shadow/2508.tmp.12835 Mon Jul 9 10:36:19 2001 *************** *** 2,9 **** | When validating turned on, XML with no DTD is reporting to be invalid | +----------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Bug #: 2508 Product: Xerces-J | ! | Status: NEW Version: 1.4 | ! | Resolution: Platform: PC | | Severity: Blocker OS/Version: Windows NT/2K | | Priority: Other Component: DTD | +----------------------------------------------------------------------------+ --- 2,9 ---- | When validating turned on, XML with no DTD is reporting to be invalid | +----------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Bug #: 2508 Product: Xerces-J | ! | Status: RESOLVED Version: 1.4 | ! | Resolution: INVALID Platform: PC | | Severity: Blocker OS/Version: Windows NT/2K | | Priority: Other Component: DTD | +----------------------------------------------------------------------------+ *************** *** 22,25 **** declared. The XML should not be getting validated since it has no DTD reference. This seems to be a pretty big problem, however searching through the bug ! database noone has reported it? --- 22,32 ---- declared. The XML should not be getting validated since it has no DTD reference. This seems to be a pretty big problem, however searching through the bug ! database noone has reported it? ! ! ------- Additional Comments From [EMAIL PROTECTED] 2001-07-09 10:36 ------- ! From the XML 1.0 2nd edition, section 2.8, we have: "Definition: An XML ! document is valid if it has an associated document type declaration and if the ! document complies with the constraints expressed in it." Thus, if an XML ! document has no document type declaration it can't be valid and the parser is ! right to produce an error if validation is turned on for such a document. --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
