the personal emails that surfaced in our discussion must be taken back where they started...we dont need this.
*The matter is Closed*, if comrades want to continue must do that outside this forum, cos now its personal, as it started with personal email please keep it there... please respect other users of this forum, Amandla!! Sibusiso On 12/10/08, KGALE GODFREY MAILA <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > I couldn't agree with you more Cde Makopole, you are correct, as for > Tsembeyi, I think he should have known that the political intolerance > has currently reached boiling levels in the country. It has > unfortunately ,successfully smuggled its ugly head in this critical > forum. I would, with respect, urge you Cde Tsembeyi to just agree with > whatever issue is raised, that sound more in the spirit of triumphalism, > any other issue, even in furture, OR atleast pause a bit, cause you will > soon be called "a dead snake, or the dog" > > They have already started calling you "a Bolshevik" > > HASTA LA VICTORIA SIEMPRE > > > > > >>> [EMAIL PROTECTED] 12/10/08 1:41 PM >>> > Comrades > > > > It's very disturbing that internal affairs are now being brought out > into public domains where everybody can see that there is disharmony > within our structures ,lets have respect for the processes that have > been started and respect the principle that says innocent till proven > otherwise, I am actually very surprised that certain comrades are taking > issues like this to this forum whereby the whole idea of this was to > share political education,ideas and discuss current issues of major > importance. > > > > Please gentlemen lets us not lose sight of important matters and resort > to this current mudslinging we are engaged in. > > > > Thank you, > > Erick Makopole Mokgabudi > > > > "In every triumph there`s a lot `try`: Frank Tyger > > From: [email protected] > [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Vusi Makamu > (CF) > Sent: 10 December 2008 01:26 > To: [email protected] > Subject: [YCLSA Discussion] Re: Thanks and some few words > > > > Cde Tsembeyi I'm surprised that you have chosen to be a self appointed > spokes person of the suspended comrades in your statement its look like > you have much interest about the circumstances of their suspension ,We > are all agree that they are innocent until proven guilty of the > allegations against them hence the suspension.It will serve no purpose > for this forum to be turned into be CC disciplinary committee and deal > with matters around the suspension of Zico and others. > > these cdes will prove their innocent in the disciplinary committee and > let us focus on issues that this forum has been created for obviously > its not the intention of this forum to discuss personalities so let us > not go there. > > > Amandla > > ________________________________ > > From: [email protected] > [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of sithembewena > tsembeyi > Sent: 10/12/2008 01:02 PM > To: [email protected] > Subject: [YCLSA Discussion] Re: Thanks and some few words > > As I have said before if being an advancer of the true reflections of > the communist concept is a crime in the organisation I am prepared to > face the music, and would undoubtatly declear my guilt. > > I am not apologetic in any of the comments I have made in reference > with my statement and it is true that the party is indeed > not a privete company that belongs to anyone, we all subscribe to the > idiology yes thats the fact, We can not allow that anyone to come and > pose threats that by participating with cleare principle should be the > victim of cercumstances. > > > > I would take from Dominics word and say "so be it". > > my intention was not to solicit your support to subvert the diciplinary > process of the party, but to keep you inline with with current > occerances within the party. If anyone were to be suspended based on > alligations that he or she attended a particular gathering or invited to > be part of a forum that is suspected to be an initiation of a splinter > group in the party, it also sugests that through consistancy anyone who > will be alledged to be a member of a reactionary movement whiles leading > the party or organise a cope rally should also be suspended and > investigated later. but in this case it seems there is no consistance > since Zico and others were suspended before investigations with those > whome are alledged to have been members of the reactionarry movement and > those who sponcered cope rally in ekurhuleni we are told that they will > first be investigated before being suspended. > > > > I dont have to tell you who those poeple are,coz its very clear to me > that you voluntarily chose to be their subject. > > > > HASTA LA VICTORIA SIEMPRE > --- On Tue, 12/9/08, Dominic Tweedie <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote > > From: Dominic Tweedie <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Subject: [YCLSA Discussion] Thanks and some few words > To: [email protected] > Date: Tuesday, December 9, 2008, 6:48 AM > > Thanks for the messages of appreciation, comrades. > > > > To Sithembewena Tsembeyi, I want to say the following: > > > > You wrote to me privately to solicit my support to subvert the > disciplinary process of the Party. I wrote back to you personally to > advise you in a comradely way to desist from doing that, and to wait for > the process to run through. You took my message and posted it on this > forum. > > > > So be it. > > > > Let me make myself a little bit more clear about this. The Party > can tolerate a great deal, but what it cannot tolerate is for any member > to have a secret or a defiant loyalty that is held by that member to be > higher than his loyalty to the Party and its duly-elected leadership. > > > > If you are serving some other cause than that of the Party, then > you are in the Party in bad faith, and the only honourable way out of > that situation is to leave, or to else re-submit yourself to the > Party's discipline and abandon your other master. > > > > This is not about Zico, Comrade Sithembewena, or anybody else > but yourself. > > > > This Party is not divided between "Bolsheviks" and others. > You may not go around getting up a faction within our SACP. It is not > permissible for you to go around denouncing other Party comrades as > Mensheviks or thugs. These words are put from a Party point of view, and > not as moderator of this forum, which is a different matter. > > > > To other comrades, let me repeat some things that I have written > here before. > > > > I moderate this forum, for the time being, and until some other > person comes forward to take over. That means I filter out the spam (a > very tedious job) and do some other technical things. As a rule, I do > not censor or ban. The forum must find its own level and must solve its > ideological problems in dialogue. If it cannot do this much for itself, > it might as well pack up. But in fact it does very well and I have no > complaints. > > > > My main job at the moment is the production of COSATU Today and > the COSATU Media Monitor. To subscribe for these two go to > http://groups-beta.google.com/group/COSATU-Daily-News > <http://groups-beta.google.com/group/COSATU-Daily-News> . > > > > From time to time I post selected material that I gather for > those publications on to this forum. Usually these would be items that > need discussion. In other words, they are posted not so much to assert > any fact or point of view, but rather to invite peoples' views and to > gain some further understanding from that dialogue. The value of the > forum is that it can help sort out problems. > > > > The City Press article about what Mluleki George is alleged to > have claimed about Thabo Mbeki is a good example of such an open-ended > question. Contrary to what has been said, the journalist Moffet Mofokeng > did a very good job. He did his own research and he got clear quotes > from both sides, including from an individual who was present when > George is alleged to have made his remarks. This was a good story and a > worthy front-page lead. We will find out who is right and who is wrong > in due course. Maybe some Eastern Cape comrades can assist, right here. > > > > > I am very short of time. I would have loved to have intervened > sooner in this discussion, but I hardly have any time, comrades. > > > > Cde Sbu, I see your message which arrived just as I was > finishing this. I appreciate your wisdom as always. > > > > Domza, VC. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You are subscribed. This footer can help you. Please POST your comments to [email protected] or reply to this message. You can visit the group WEB SITE at http://groups.google.com/group/yclsa-eom-forum for different delivery options, pages, files and membership. To UNSUBSCRIBE, please email [EMAIL PROTECTED] . You don't have to put anything in the "Subject:" field. You don't have to put anything in the message part. All you have to do is to send an e-mail to this address (repeat): [EMAIL PROTECTED] . -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
