Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
Talks are a great way to spread the word about the project so don't hesitate to update the respective part of the website as soon as the talk is announced. On Wed, Oct 30, 2019 at 5:16 AM Juan Pan wrote: > Sorry to disturb others. > > > @Danny Chan Hi, i have not received your personal mail, and i sent you > email(yuzhao@gmail.com?) as well, but no reply. :( > > > > So i have to ping you in this way, please excuse me. > > > > > > > Juan Pan > > > panj...@apache.org > Juan Pan(Trista), Apache ShardingSphere > > > On 10/25/2019 20:41，Danny Chan wrote： > Oh, you can add my weixin(send personal mail for that) and I have a free > ticket for the conference ! > > Best, > Danny Chan > 在 2019年10月25日 +0800 PM6:29，Juan Pan ，写道： > Hi Danny, > > > I am interested in your coming talk in Beijing China. How to take part in > it, can you give me more detail? > > > Juan Pan > > > panj...@apache.org > Juan Pan(Trista), Apache ShardingSphere > > > On 10/23/2019 18:23，Danny Chan wrote： > I gave a talk last year in a university in > France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before. > > Oops, that's a pity, I would also give a talk about Calcite on Flink > Forward Asia 2019 of BeiJing China, hope more people would know Apache > Calcite. > > Best, > Danny Chan > 在 2019年10月23日 +0800 PM2:36，dev@calcite.apache.org，写道： > > I gave a talk last year in a university in > France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before. >
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
Sorry to disturb others. @Danny Chan Hi, i have not received your personal mail, and i sent you email(yuzhao@gmail.com?) as well, but no reply. :( So i have to ping you in this way, please excuse me. Juan Pan panj...@apache.org Juan Pan(Trista), Apache ShardingSphere On 10/25/2019 20:41，Danny Chan wrote： Oh, you can add my weixin(send personal mail for that) and I have a free ticket for the conference ! Best, Danny Chan 在 2019年10月25日 +0800 PM6:29，Juan Pan ，写道： Hi Danny, I am interested in your coming talk in Beijing China. How to take part in it, can you give me more detail? Juan Pan panj...@apache.org Juan Pan(Trista), Apache ShardingSphere On 10/23/2019 18:23，Danny Chan wrote： I gave a talk last year in a university in France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before. Oops, that's a pity, I would also give a talk about Calcite on Flink Forward Asia 2019 of BeiJing China, hope more people would know Apache Calcite. Best, Danny Chan 在 2019年10月23日 +0800 PM2:36，dev@calcite.apache.org，写道： I gave a talk last year in a university in France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before.
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
Oh, you can add my weixin(send personal mail for that) and I have a free ticket for the conference ! Best, Danny Chan 在 2019年10月25日 +0800 PM6:29，Juan Pan ，写道： > Hi Danny, > > > I am interested in your coming talk in Beijing China. How to take part in it, > can you give me more detail? > > > Juan Pan > > > panj...@apache.org > Juan Pan(Trista), Apache ShardingSphere > > > On 10/23/2019 18:23，Danny Chan wrote： > I gave a talk last year in a university in > France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before. > > Oops, that's a pity, I would also give a talk about Calcite on Flink Forward > Asia 2019 of BeiJing China, hope more people would know Apache Calcite. > > Best, > Danny Chan > 在 2019年10月23日 +0800 PM2:36，dev@calcite.apache.org，写道： > > I gave a talk last year in a university in > France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before.
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
Hi Danny, I am interested in your coming talk in Beijing China. How to take part in it, can you give me more detail? Juan Pan panj...@apache.org Juan Pan(Trista), Apache ShardingSphere On 10/23/2019 18:23，Danny Chan wrote： I gave a talk last year in a university in France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before. Oops, that's a pity, I would also give a talk about Calcite on Flink Forward Asia 2019 of BeiJing China, hope more people would know Apache Calcite. Best, Danny Chan 在 2019年10月23日 +0800 PM2:36，dev@calcite.apache.org，写道： I gave a talk last year in a university in France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before.
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
Thanks a lot for your work Francis and +1 for Stamatis to be the next PMC chair ~ ~ Calcite is a great project and it offers as a strong SQL engine to help users to build data systems. My group uses Calcite to accelerate SQLs from multiple data engines by heuristic based, cost based and materialization based optimization. As a developer, I really benefit a lot from Calcite and the help from this great community. Calcite is not well known ? Yes, it might be less heard by the end users (who focus on data analysis), but most of data engine developers (AFAIK) know that Calcite is always a good choice when they want to build a strong SQL engine for their data systems. This is the charm of Calcite. Finally, I agree with Muhammad Gelbana to strenghten documentation for Calcite. Best, Jin Alessandro Solimando 于2019年10月24日周四 下午4:41写道： > Hello, > I have the impression too that Calcite is lesser known than other Apache > projects, but this is not that surprising to me given the nature of the > project itself, which requires in-depth knowledge of a rather complex > topic, which makes it is less prone to a casual use and plug adoption. > But IMO this is a point of strength and not a weakness, and it's what makes > Calcite so fascinating! This been said, spreading the word never hurts. > > I also agree that the community is much more active now than in the past > two years, the effort has always been high but now there are more people > involved, which makes it easier. > > On my side I mostly follow the "high-level" discussions more than the > individual tickets. Such discussions are constructive, pleasant to read and > instructive. > > A big plus also for the high-quality research articles directly stemming > from the efforts of this community. > > Last but not least, Stamatis would make a great PMC chair! > > I take the chance to thank you all for the great deal of effort in keeping > the project alive at such high standards. > > Best regards, > Alessandro > > > > On Wed, 23 Oct 2019 at 17:00, Ruben Q L wrote: > > > Hello everyone, > > > > First of all, thanks for your work, Francis. > > > > While I am relatively new in this community I must admit that I totally > > agree with Danny Chan when he says that we had some *"interesting > > discussions on the mailing list and we did have some valuable > > conclusion(like the Join expression rework, the trait sets propagation, > the > > metadata etc.)"*. I think we must continue in this direction and keep on > > our good work together. > > > > Apart from that, I agree with Muhammad Gelbana too: ideally we could have > > more technical documentation of the main modules; but I am also aware > that > > it can be very time consuming to generate such documentation, and also to > > maintain it, and we could easily have out-of-date material on our hands. > > So, I am not sure how we could proceed. > > Despite being a great project, I also have the impression that Calcite is > > not so well-known, and we need to "spread the word" to reach a bigger > > number of users. > > > > I cannot compare with previous years, but I what I have seen so far is a > > healthy community, with many people collaborating and willing to help > > beginner (and advanced) users. > > > > Finally, I think Stamatis is a great choice for PMC chair :) > > > > Best, > > Ruben Quesada Lopez > > > > > > > > Le mer. 23 oct. 2019 à 15:09, Michael Mior a écrit : > > > > > Thanks for the summary Francis and +1 for Stamatis as the next PMC > chair > > :) > > > > > > -- > > > Michael Mior > > > mm...@apache.org > > > > > > Le mer. 23 oct. 2019 à 02:36, Stamatis Zampetakis > a > > > écrit : > > > > > > > > It's been a great year so far. Thanks for your great work Francis, > you > > > did > > > > an excellent job! > > > > > > > > I also like a lot the way that the mailing list works and the fact > that > > > we > > > > are very active. Apart from helping each other it also centralizes a > > lot > > > of > > > > information, where people may find an answer to their problem quite > > > easily. > > > > When I first started to learn about Calcite, the list and the > archives > > > were > > > > indispensable. > > > > > > > > It is also very positive that we don't encounter very often > regressions > > > > (and most of those encountered were minor), which shows that the > > quality > > > > standards of the project are really high and reviewers are really > > paying > > > > attention on what is going in. I believe a lot in the motto of > quality > > > over > > > > quantity. > > > > > > > > Although we are managing PRs a bit better than the previous years, we > > > have > > > > to improve more. I had in my mind that if people assigned to > themselves > > > the > > > > review of the JIRA/PR the feeling of responsibility would make things > > > > advance faster. I tried applying this to myself but it didn't really > > work > > > > much better since there is certainly a lack of time. Other than lack > of > > > > time
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
Hello, I have the impression too that Calcite is lesser known than other Apache projects, but this is not that surprising to me given the nature of the project itself, which requires in-depth knowledge of a rather complex topic, which makes it is less prone to a casual use and plug adoption. But IMO this is a point of strength and not a weakness, and it's what makes Calcite so fascinating! This been said, spreading the word never hurts. I also agree that the community is much more active now than in the past two years, the effort has always been high but now there are more people involved, which makes it easier. On my side I mostly follow the "high-level" discussions more than the individual tickets. Such discussions are constructive, pleasant to read and instructive. A big plus also for the high-quality research articles directly stemming from the efforts of this community. Last but not least, Stamatis would make a great PMC chair! I take the chance to thank you all for the great deal of effort in keeping the project alive at such high standards. Best regards, Alessandro On Wed, 23 Oct 2019 at 17:00, Ruben Q L wrote: > Hello everyone, > > First of all, thanks for your work, Francis. > > While I am relatively new in this community I must admit that I totally > agree with Danny Chan when he says that we had some *"interesting > discussions on the mailing list and we did have some valuable > conclusion(like the Join expression rework, the trait sets propagation, the > metadata etc.)"*. I think we must continue in this direction and keep on > our good work together. > > Apart from that, I agree with Muhammad Gelbana too: ideally we could have > more technical documentation of the main modules; but I am also aware that > it can be very time consuming to generate such documentation, and also to > maintain it, and we could easily have out-of-date material on our hands. > So, I am not sure how we could proceed. > Despite being a great project, I also have the impression that Calcite is > not so well-known, and we need to "spread the word" to reach a bigger > number of users. > > I cannot compare with previous years, but I what I have seen so far is a > healthy community, with many people collaborating and willing to help > beginner (and advanced) users. > > Finally, I think Stamatis is a great choice for PMC chair :) > > Best, > Ruben Quesada Lopez > > > > Le mer. 23 oct. 2019 à 15:09, Michael Mior a écrit : > > > Thanks for the summary Francis and +1 for Stamatis as the next PMC chair > :) > > > > -- > > Michael Mior > > mm...@apache.org > > > > Le mer. 23 oct. 2019 à 02:36, Stamatis Zampetakis a > > écrit : > > > > > > It's been a great year so far. Thanks for your great work Francis, you > > did > > > an excellent job! > > > > > > I also like a lot the way that the mailing list works and the fact that > > we > > > are very active. Apart from helping each other it also centralizes a > lot > > of > > > information, where people may find an answer to their problem quite > > easily. > > > When I first started to learn about Calcite, the list and the archives > > were > > > indispensable. > > > > > > It is also very positive that we don't encounter very often regressions > > > (and most of those encountered were minor), which shows that the > quality > > > standards of the project are really high and reviewers are really > paying > > > attention on what is going in. I believe a lot in the motto of quality > > over > > > quantity. > > > > > > Although we are managing PRs a bit better than the previous years, we > > have > > > to improve more. I had in my mind that if people assigned to themselves > > the > > > review of the JIRA/PR the feeling of responsibility would make things > > > advance faster. I tried applying this to myself but it didn't really > work > > > much better since there is certainly a lack of time. Other than lack of > > > time sometimes it is our diligence that makes PRs wait a long time till > > > they get merged. Given that we have a version control system (and at > any > > > time we can go back in time) we should be more confident about > committing > > > things faster. > > > > > > Calcite is a great project that could be used in many different ways by > > > many people. Unfortunately, I think we are losing many users simply > > because > > > they are not aware that such a project exists. At least in Europe, > > academic > > > people and as a result university students, graduates, and future > > engineers > > > do not know that Calcite exists. I gave a talk last year in a > university > > in > > > France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before. I > > > think such introductory talks in universities should be done more > often. > > > The talks about Calcite in conferences is of course a great way to > spread > > > the word; thanks to everybody who got involved in them and keep it up. > > > > > > Thanks a lot for the nomination for PMC chair! I will be honoured
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
Hello everyone, First of all, thanks for your work, Francis. While I am relatively new in this community I must admit that I totally agree with Danny Chan when he says that we had some *"interesting discussions on the mailing list and we did have some valuable conclusion(like the Join expression rework, the trait sets propagation, the metadata etc.)"*. I think we must continue in this direction and keep on our good work together. Apart from that, I agree with Muhammad Gelbana too: ideally we could have more technical documentation of the main modules; but I am also aware that it can be very time consuming to generate such documentation, and also to maintain it, and we could easily have out-of-date material on our hands. So, I am not sure how we could proceed. Despite being a great project, I also have the impression that Calcite is not so well-known, and we need to "spread the word" to reach a bigger number of users. I cannot compare with previous years, but I what I have seen so far is a healthy community, with many people collaborating and willing to help beginner (and advanced) users. Finally, I think Stamatis is a great choice for PMC chair :) Best, Ruben Quesada Lopez Le mer. 23 oct. 2019 à 15:09, Michael Mior a écrit : > Thanks for the summary Francis and +1 for Stamatis as the next PMC chair :) > > -- > Michael Mior > mm...@apache.org > > Le mer. 23 oct. 2019 à 02:36, Stamatis Zampetakis a > écrit : > > > > It's been a great year so far. Thanks for your great work Francis, you > did > > an excellent job! > > > > I also like a lot the way that the mailing list works and the fact that > we > > are very active. Apart from helping each other it also centralizes a lot > of > > information, where people may find an answer to their problem quite > easily. > > When I first started to learn about Calcite, the list and the archives > were > > indispensable. > > > > It is also very positive that we don't encounter very often regressions > > (and most of those encountered were minor), which shows that the quality > > standards of the project are really high and reviewers are really paying > > attention on what is going in. I believe a lot in the motto of quality > over > > quantity. > > > > Although we are managing PRs a bit better than the previous years, we > have > > to improve more. I had in my mind that if people assigned to themselves > the > > review of the JIRA/PR the feeling of responsibility would make things > > advance faster. I tried applying this to myself but it didn't really work > > much better since there is certainly a lack of time. Other than lack of > > time sometimes it is our diligence that makes PRs wait a long time till > > they get merged. Given that we have a version control system (and at any > > time we can go back in time) we should be more confident about committing > > things faster. > > > > Calcite is a great project that could be used in many different ways by > > many people. Unfortunately, I think we are losing many users simply > because > > they are not aware that such a project exists. At least in Europe, > academic > > people and as a result university students, graduates, and future > engineers > > do not know that Calcite exists. I gave a talk last year in a university > in > > France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before. I > > think such introductory talks in universities should be done more often. > > The talks about Calcite in conferences is of course a great way to spread > > the word; thanks to everybody who got involved in them and keep it up. > > > > Thanks a lot for the nomination for PMC chair! I will be honoured and > very > > happy to serve if I am elected. > > > > Best, > > Stamatis > > > > On Wed, Oct 23, 2019 at 6:40 AM Juan Pan wrote: > > > > > Hi everyone, > > > > > > > > > Actually i think it's time to have my say after receiving the email > > > titiled `Have your say!` from Julian Hyde. > > > > > > > > > As a person new this project, i am appreciated community's help for my > > > question ml, and glad to see its communnity so active and harmonious. > Other > > > than that, it also gives me some new ideas for our incubator project. > As of > > > now, i am exploring Calcite, so if possible, i want to do some > > > contributions to it as well. > > > > > > > > > Hope Apache Calcite better and better in future. > > > > > > > > > Best wishes, > > > Trista > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Juan Pan > > > > > > > > > panj...@apache.org > > > Juan Pan(Trista), Apache ShardingSphere > > > > > > > > > On 10/23/2019 11:21，Chunwei Lei wrote： > > > Thank you for your great work, Francis! > > > > > > In the past year, I deeply feel that Calcite community is becoming > more and > > > more active, which means that more and > > > more companies start to use Apache Calcite. This is very exciting and > > > encouraging. > > > > > > Thanks to active contributions and committers, pull requests could be > > > reviewed and merged in a short
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
Thanks for the summary Francis and +1 for Stamatis as the next PMC chair :) -- Michael Mior mm...@apache.org Le mer. 23 oct. 2019 à 02:36, Stamatis Zampetakis a écrit : > > It's been a great year so far. Thanks for your great work Francis, you did > an excellent job! > > I also like a lot the way that the mailing list works and the fact that we > are very active. Apart from helping each other it also centralizes a lot of > information, where people may find an answer to their problem quite easily. > When I first started to learn about Calcite, the list and the archives were > indispensable. > > It is also very positive that we don't encounter very often regressions > (and most of those encountered were minor), which shows that the quality > standards of the project are really high and reviewers are really paying > attention on what is going in. I believe a lot in the motto of quality over > quantity. > > Although we are managing PRs a bit better than the previous years, we have > to improve more. I had in my mind that if people assigned to themselves the > review of the JIRA/PR the feeling of responsibility would make things > advance faster. I tried applying this to myself but it didn't really work > much better since there is certainly a lack of time. Other than lack of > time sometimes it is our diligence that makes PRs wait a long time till > they get merged. Given that we have a version control system (and at any > time we can go back in time) we should be more confident about committing > things faster. > > Calcite is a great project that could be used in many different ways by > many people. Unfortunately, I think we are losing many users simply because > they are not aware that such a project exists. At least in Europe, academic > people and as a result university students, graduates, and future engineers > do not know that Calcite exists. I gave a talk last year in a university in > France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before. I > think such introductory talks in universities should be done more often. > The talks about Calcite in conferences is of course a great way to spread > the word; thanks to everybody who got involved in them and keep it up. > > Thanks a lot for the nomination for PMC chair! I will be honoured and very > happy to serve if I am elected. > > Best, > Stamatis > > On Wed, Oct 23, 2019 at 6:40 AM Juan Pan wrote: > > > Hi everyone, > > > > > > Actually i think it's time to have my say after receiving the email > > titiled `Have your say!` from Julian Hyde. > > > > > > As a person new this project, i am appreciated community's help for my > > question ml, and glad to see its communnity so active and harmonious. Other > > than that, it also gives me some new ideas for our incubator project. As of > > now, i am exploring Calcite, so if possible, i want to do some > > contributions to it as well. > > > > > > Hope Apache Calcite better and better in future. > > > > > > Best wishes, > > Trista > > > > > > > > > > Juan Pan > > > > > > panj...@apache.org > > Juan Pan(Trista), Apache ShardingSphere > > > > > > On 10/23/2019 11:21，Chunwei Lei wrote： > > Thank you for your great work, Francis! > > > > In the past year, I deeply feel that Calcite community is becoming more and > > more active, which means that more and > > more companies start to use Apache Calcite. This is very exciting and > > encouraging. > > > > Thanks to active contributions and committers, pull requests could be > > reviewed and merged in a short time currently > > which really benefits a lot. > > > > I also feel that there are quite a few tough legacy issues left. I hope we > > can spend more time discussing and finding out > > a solution in the future. > > > > Thanks! > > > > Best, > > Chunwei > > > > > > On Wed, Oct 23, 2019 at 9:38 AM Danny Chan wrote: > > > > Thanks for the state summarize Francis Chuang ! And thanks for the awesome > > work for keeping Calcite in good shape ! > > > > From my perspective, I really feel that Calcite is becoming more and more > > popular and there are many new groups trying to use this great project, as > > a reviewer, I saw many contributions from all kinds of people. And I feel > > very proud of that ! > > > > For the last year, I did many work to let Apache Flink and Calcite to have > > better integration, and I believe there would be more and more people to > > make contributions and make Calcite more pluggable and more suitable for > > production environments ! > > > > I also very enjoy the absolute harmony of the community, we are fire > > interesting discussions on the mailing list and we did have some valuable > > conclusion(like the Join expression rework, the trait sets propagation, the > > metadata etc.) And I felt very happy and respected to work with you guys in > > the community. Let’s keep the good communications and output more valuable > > design ! > > > > Thanks again to everyone ! > > > > Best, > > Danny Chan > > 在 2019年10月22日 +0800
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
I forgot mentioning that I strongly believe we need more technical design documents for Calcite's major components such as the parser, validator and code generation. On Wed, Oct 23, 2019 at 12:52 PM Muhammad Gelbana wrote: > The mailing list didn't have such activity three years ago when I started > learning about Calcite. Also more advanced topics and questions are posted > which, although makes it harder for me to participate, it definitely says a > lot about how much the project has advanced on both the technical and > adoption aspects. > > +1 for Stamatis for PMC chair. He's one of the most active, knowledgable > and friendliest committers I've come across. > > > > On Wed, Oct 23, 2019 at 12:23 PM Danny Chan wrote: > >> >I gave a talk last year in a university in >> > France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before. >> >> Oops, that's a pity, I would also give a talk about Calcite on Flink >> Forward Asia 2019 of BeiJing China, hope more people would know Apache >> Calcite. >> >> Best, >> Danny Chan >> 在 2019年10月23日 +0800 PM2:36，dev@calcite.apache.org，写道： >> > >> > I gave a talk last year in a university in >> > France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before. >> >
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
The mailing list didn't have such activity three years ago when I started learning about Calcite. Also more advanced topics and questions are posted which, although makes it harder for me to participate, it definitely says a lot about how much the project has advanced on both the technical and adoption aspects. +1 for Stamatis for PMC chair. He's one of the most active, knowledgable and friendliest committers I've come across. On Wed, Oct 23, 2019 at 12:23 PM Danny Chan wrote: > >I gave a talk last year in a university in > > France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before. > > Oops, that's a pity, I would also give a talk about Calcite on Flink > Forward Asia 2019 of BeiJing China, hope more people would know Apache > Calcite. > > Best, > Danny Chan > 在 2019年10月23日 +0800 PM2:36，dev@calcite.apache.org，写道： > > > > I gave a talk last year in a university in > > France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before. >
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
>I gave a talk last year in a university in > France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before. Oops, that's a pity, I would also give a talk about Calcite on Flink Forward Asia 2019 of BeiJing China, hope more people would know Apache Calcite. Best, Danny Chan 在 2019年10月23日 +0800 PM2:36，dev@calcite.apache.org，写道： > > I gave a talk last year in a university in > France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before.
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
It's been a great year so far. Thanks for your great work Francis, you did an excellent job! I also like a lot the way that the mailing list works and the fact that we are very active. Apart from helping each other it also centralizes a lot of information, where people may find an answer to their problem quite easily. When I first started to learn about Calcite, the list and the archives were indispensable. It is also very positive that we don't encounter very often regressions (and most of those encountered were minor), which shows that the quality standards of the project are really high and reviewers are really paying attention on what is going in. I believe a lot in the motto of quality over quantity. Although we are managing PRs a bit better than the previous years, we have to improve more. I had in my mind that if people assigned to themselves the review of the JIRA/PR the feeling of responsibility would make things advance faster. I tried applying this to myself but it didn't really work much better since there is certainly a lack of time. Other than lack of time sometimes it is our diligence that makes PRs wait a long time till they get merged. Given that we have a version control system (and at any time we can go back in time) we should be more confident about committing things faster. Calcite is a great project that could be used in many different ways by many people. Unfortunately, I think we are losing many users simply because they are not aware that such a project exists. At least in Europe, academic people and as a result university students, graduates, and future engineers do not know that Calcite exists. I gave a talk last year in a university in France, and nobody in the audience had ever heard of Calcite before. I think such introductory talks in universities should be done more often. The talks about Calcite in conferences is of course a great way to spread the word; thanks to everybody who got involved in them and keep it up. Thanks a lot for the nomination for PMC chair! I will be honoured and very happy to serve if I am elected. Best, Stamatis On Wed, Oct 23, 2019 at 6:40 AM Juan Pan wrote: > Hi everyone, > > > Actually i think it's time to have my say after receiving the email > titiled `Have your say!` from Julian Hyde. > > > As a person new this project, i am appreciated community's help for my > question ml, and glad to see its communnity so active and harmonious. Other > than that, it also gives me some new ideas for our incubator project. As of > now, i am exploring Calcite, so if possible, i want to do some > contributions to it as well. > > > Hope Apache Calcite better and better in future. > > > Best wishes, > Trista > > > > > Juan Pan > > > panj...@apache.org > Juan Pan(Trista), Apache ShardingSphere > > > On 10/23/2019 11:21，Chunwei Lei wrote： > Thank you for your great work, Francis! > > In the past year, I deeply feel that Calcite community is becoming more and > more active, which means that more and > more companies start to use Apache Calcite. This is very exciting and > encouraging. > > Thanks to active contributions and committers, pull requests could be > reviewed and merged in a short time currently > which really benefits a lot. > > I also feel that there are quite a few tough legacy issues left. I hope we > can spend more time discussing and finding out > a solution in the future. > > Thanks! > > Best, > Chunwei > > > On Wed, Oct 23, 2019 at 9:38 AM Danny Chan wrote: > > Thanks for the state summarize Francis Chuang ! And thanks for the awesome > work for keeping Calcite in good shape ! > > From my perspective, I really feel that Calcite is becoming more and more > popular and there are many new groups trying to use this great project, as > a reviewer, I saw many contributions from all kinds of people. And I feel > very proud of that ! > > For the last year, I did many work to let Apache Flink and Calcite to have > better integration, and I believe there would be more and more people to > make contributions and make Calcite more pluggable and more suitable for > production environments ! > > I also very enjoy the absolute harmony of the community, we are fire > interesting discussions on the mailing list and we did have some valuable > conclusion(like the Join expression rework, the trait sets propagation, the > metadata etc.) And I felt very happy and respected to work with you guys in > the community. Let’s keep the good communications and output more valuable > design ! > > Thanks again to everyone ! > > Best, > Danny Chan > 在 2019年10月22日 +0800 AM10:22，Julian Hyde ，写道： > I agree that we’ve made good progress on last year’s big problem, pull > requests languishing for too long. The situation has been better, because a > few people are putting in considerable effort reviewing. We still have some > ways to go, so let’s keep up the good work. > > One of the successes of the year was to arrange release managers for > several releases in advance. Each
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
Hi everyone, Actually i think it's time to have my say after receiving the email titiled `Have your say!` from Julian Hyde. As a person new this project, i am appreciated community's help for my question ml, and glad to see its communnity so active and harmonious. Other than that, it also gives me some new ideas for our incubator project. As of now, i am exploring Calcite, so if possible, i want to do some contributions to it as well. Hope Apache Calcite better and better in future. Best wishes, Trista Juan Pan panj...@apache.org Juan Pan(Trista), Apache ShardingSphere On 10/23/2019 11:21，Chunwei Lei wrote： Thank you for your great work, Francis! In the past year, I deeply feel that Calcite community is becoming more and more active, which means that more and more companies start to use Apache Calcite. This is very exciting and encouraging. Thanks to active contributions and committers, pull requests could be reviewed and merged in a short time currently which really benefits a lot. I also feel that there are quite a few tough legacy issues left. I hope we can spend more time discussing and finding out a solution in the future. Thanks! Best, Chunwei On Wed, Oct 23, 2019 at 9:38 AM Danny Chan wrote: Thanks for the state summarize Francis Chuang ! And thanks for the awesome work for keeping Calcite in good shape ! From my perspective, I really feel that Calcite is becoming more and more popular and there are many new groups trying to use this great project, as a reviewer, I saw many contributions from all kinds of people. And I feel very proud of that ! For the last year, I did many work to let Apache Flink and Calcite to have better integration, and I believe there would be more and more people to make contributions and make Calcite more pluggable and more suitable for production environments ! I also very enjoy the absolute harmony of the community, we are fire interesting discussions on the mailing list and we did have some valuable conclusion(like the Join expression rework, the trait sets propagation, the metadata etc.) And I felt very happy and respected to work with you guys in the community. Let’s keep the good communications and output more valuable design ! Thanks again to everyone ! Best, Danny Chan 在 2019年10月22日 +0800 AM10:22，Julian Hyde ，写道： I agree that we’ve made good progress on last year’s big problem, pull requests languishing for too long. The situation has been better, because a few people are putting in considerable effort reviewing. We still have some ways to go, so let’s keep up the good work. One of the successes of the year was to arrange release managers for several releases in advance. Each of the individuals stepped up and did a great job, and the release process was as smooth as it could possibly be for a project of this size. Because the work was shared, I think no individual felt that they were taking on an undue burden. I also want to mention the fact that we now have an awesome logo. Thank you for pushing that change through! +1 for Stamatis as candidate for the next PMC chair. I was going to propose him also. I am proud that we have appointed a new person as PMC chair every year. Each chair has brought a new perspective and energy to the role, and has advanced the community. Francis is no exception, and he has kept Calcite in good shape. Thank you, Francis! We were discussing in another thread about whether we should cleave Avatica into a more separate sub-project or top-level project. But I do note that Francis came from the Avatica side of the project (Avatica Go, in fact) and yet effortlessly and effectively spoke for the whole Calcite project. So, it gives me hope that there is still cohesion between the Calcite and Avatica communities. Julian On Oct 20, 2019, at 6:50 PM, Danny Chan wrote: Great work Francis! I’m + 1 for Stamatis being the PMC chair ~ Best, Danny Chan 在 2019年10月21日 +0800 AM6:47，dev@calcite.apache.org，写道： Francis
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
Thank you for your great work, Francis! In the past year, I deeply feel that Calcite community is becoming more and more active, which means that more and more companies start to use Apache Calcite. This is very exciting and encouraging. Thanks to active contributions and committers, pull requests could be reviewed and merged in a short time currently which really benefits a lot. I also feel that there are quite a few tough legacy issues left. I hope we can spend more time discussing and finding out a solution in the future. Thanks! Best, Chunwei On Wed, Oct 23, 2019 at 9:38 AM Danny Chan wrote: > Thanks for the state summarize Francis Chuang ! And thanks for the awesome > work for keeping Calcite in good shape ! > > From my perspective, I really feel that Calcite is becoming more and more > popular and there are many new groups trying to use this great project, as > a reviewer, I saw many contributions from all kinds of people. And I feel > very proud of that ! > > For the last year, I did many work to let Apache Flink and Calcite to have > better integration, and I believe there would be more and more people to > make contributions and make Calcite more pluggable and more suitable for > production environments ! > > I also very enjoy the absolute harmony of the community, we are fire > interesting discussions on the mailing list and we did have some valuable > conclusion(like the Join expression rework, the trait sets propagation, the > metadata etc.) And I felt very happy and respected to work with you guys in > the community. Let’s keep the good communications and output more valuable > design ! > > Thanks again to everyone ! > > Best, > Danny Chan > 在 2019年10月22日 +0800 AM10:22，Julian Hyde ，写道： > > I agree that we’ve made good progress on last year’s big problem, pull > requests languishing for too long. The situation has been better, because a > few people are putting in considerable effort reviewing. We still have some > ways to go, so let’s keep up the good work. > > > > One of the successes of the year was to arrange release managers for > several releases in advance. Each of the individuals stepped up and did a > great job, and the release process was as smooth as it could possibly be > for a project of this size. Because the work was shared, I think no > individual felt that they were taking on an undue burden. > > > > I also want to mention the fact that we now have an awesome logo. Thank > you for pushing that change through! > > > > +1 for Stamatis as candidate for the next PMC chair. I was going to > propose him also. > > > > I am proud that we have appointed a new person as PMC chair every year. > Each chair has brought a new perspective and energy to the role, and has > advanced the community. Francis is no exception, and he has kept Calcite in > good shape. Thank you, Francis! > > > > We were discussing in another thread about whether we should cleave > Avatica into a more separate sub-project or top-level project. But I do > note that Francis came from the Avatica side of the project (Avatica Go, in > fact) and yet effortlessly and effectively spoke for the whole Calcite > project. So, it gives me hope that there is still cohesion between the > Calcite and Avatica communities. > > > > Julian > > > > > > > On Oct 20, 2019, at 6:50 PM, Danny Chan wrote: > > > > > > Great work Francis! I’m + 1 for Stamatis being the PMC chair ~ > > > > > > Best, > > > Danny Chan > > > 在 2019年10月21日 +0800 AM6:47，dev@calcite.apache.org，写道： > > > > > > > > Francis > > >
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
Thanks for the state summarize Francis Chuang ! And thanks for the awesome work for keeping Calcite in good shape ! From my perspective, I really feel that Calcite is becoming more and more popular and there are many new groups trying to use this great project, as a reviewer, I saw many contributions from all kinds of people. And I feel very proud of that ! For the last year, I did many work to let Apache Flink and Calcite to have better integration, and I believe there would be more and more people to make contributions and make Calcite more pluggable and more suitable for production environments ! I also very enjoy the absolute harmony of the community, we are fire interesting discussions on the mailing list and we did have some valuable conclusion(like the Join expression rework, the trait sets propagation, the metadata etc.) And I felt very happy and respected to work with you guys in the community. Let’s keep the good communications and output more valuable design ! Thanks again to everyone ! Best, Danny Chan 在 2019年10月22日 +0800 AM10:22，Julian Hyde ，写道： > I agree that we’ve made good progress on last year’s big problem, pull > requests languishing for too long. The situation has been better, because a > few people are putting in considerable effort reviewing. We still have some > ways to go, so let’s keep up the good work. > > One of the successes of the year was to arrange release managers for several > releases in advance. Each of the individuals stepped up and did a great job, > and the release process was as smooth as it could possibly be for a project > of this size. Because the work was shared, I think no individual felt that > they were taking on an undue burden. > > I also want to mention the fact that we now have an awesome logo. Thank you > for pushing that change through! > > +1 for Stamatis as candidate for the next PMC chair. I was going to propose > him also. > > I am proud that we have appointed a new person as PMC chair every year. Each > chair has brought a new perspective and energy to the role, and has advanced > the community. Francis is no exception, and he has kept Calcite in good > shape. Thank you, Francis! > > We were discussing in another thread about whether we should cleave Avatica > into a more separate sub-project or top-level project. But I do note that > Francis came from the Avatica side of the project (Avatica Go, in fact) and > yet effortlessly and effectively spoke for the whole Calcite project. So, it > gives me hope that there is still cohesion between the Calcite and Avatica > communities. > > Julian > > > > On Oct 20, 2019, at 6:50 PM, Danny Chan wrote: > > > > Great work Francis! I’m + 1 for Stamatis being the PMC chair ~ > > > > Best, > > Danny Chan > > 在 2019年10月21日 +0800 AM6:47，dev@calcite.apache.org，写道： > > > > > > Francis >
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
+1 on the improvement of pull request turnaround time. I also see a few new committers who are really active. They help review PRs and answer mail list questions, which really benefits the community and people who’d like to make code contribution. I also feel like Calcite has big code base with a lot of history. It would be great if we could do more knowledge sharing, so people making changes in legacy code would have better understand on the history. Such sharing could be through documentation, talk, slices, or even code review and email discussion. We have been doing some of these, but I’d look forward to seeing more in the future. Thanks. > On Oct 21, 2019, at 7:21 PM, Julian Hyde wrote: > > I agree that we’ve made good progress on last year’s big problem, pull > requests languishing for too long. The situation has been better, because a > few people are putting in considerable effort reviewing. We still have some > ways to go, so let’s keep up the good work. > > One of the successes of the year was to arrange release managers for several > releases in advance. Each of the individuals stepped up and did a great job, > and the release process was as smooth as it could possibly be for a project > of this size. Because the work was shared, I think no individual felt that > they were taking on an undue burden. > > I also want to mention the fact that we now have an awesome logo. Thank you > for pushing that change through! > > +1 for Stamatis as candidate for the next PMC chair. I was going to propose > him also. > > I am proud that we have appointed a new person as PMC chair every year. Each > chair has brought a new perspective and energy to the role, and has advanced > the community. Francis is no exception, and he has kept Calcite in good > shape. Thank you, Francis! > > We were discussing in another thread about whether we should cleave Avatica > into a more separate sub-project or top-level project. But I do note that > Francis came from the Avatica side of the project (Avatica Go, in fact) and > yet effortlessly and effectively spoke for the whole Calcite project. So, it > gives me hope that there is still cohesion between the Calcite and Avatica > communities. > > Julian > > >> On Oct 20, 2019, at 6:50 PM, Danny Chan wrote: >> >> Great work Francis! I’m + 1 for Stamatis being the PMC chair ~ >> >> Best, >> Danny Chan >> 在 2019年10月21日 +0800 AM6:47，dev@calcite.apache.org，写道： >>> >>> Francis >
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
I agree that we’ve made good progress on last year’s big problem, pull requests languishing for too long. The situation has been better, because a few people are putting in considerable effort reviewing. We still have some ways to go, so let’s keep up the good work. One of the successes of the year was to arrange release managers for several releases in advance. Each of the individuals stepped up and did a great job, and the release process was as smooth as it could possibly be for a project of this size. Because the work was shared, I think no individual felt that they were taking on an undue burden. I also want to mention the fact that we now have an awesome logo. Thank you for pushing that change through! +1 for Stamatis as candidate for the next PMC chair. I was going to propose him also. I am proud that we have appointed a new person as PMC chair every year. Each chair has brought a new perspective and energy to the role, and has advanced the community. Francis is no exception, and he has kept Calcite in good shape. Thank you, Francis! We were discussing in another thread about whether we should cleave Avatica into a more separate sub-project or top-level project. But I do note that Francis came from the Avatica side of the project (Avatica Go, in fact) and yet effortlessly and effectively spoke for the whole Calcite project. So, it gives me hope that there is still cohesion between the Calcite and Avatica communities. Julian > On Oct 20, 2019, at 6:50 PM, Danny Chan wrote: > > Great work Francis! I’m + 1 for Stamatis being the PMC chair ~ > > Best, > Danny Chan > 在 2019年10月21日 +0800 AM6:47，dev@calcite.apache.org，写道： >> >> Francis
Re: [DISCUSS] State of the project 2019
Great work Francis! I’m + 1 for Stamatis being the PMC chair ~ Best, Danny Chan 在 2019年10月21日 +0800 AM6:47，dev@calcite.apache.org，写道： > > Francis
