RE: Scope of the House of Justice -VERY LONG

2005-02-02 Thread Susan Maneck
In The thirteenth Glad-Tidings and The eighth Ishraq, Baha'u'llah refers to The MEN of God's House of Justice as the Trustees of God. Dear Sandra, Keep in mind that originally Abdu'l-Baha applied this passage when asked why women were excluded from the Chicago House of Justice. It was later He

Re: Scope of the House of Justice -VERY LONG

2005-01-30 Thread Sandra Chamberlain
Susan: Is that what your argument is based on, capitalization? Because as far as I know there is not any convention whereby Baha'is are supposed to use upper case letters to refer to the Universal House of Justice and lower case when referring to other institutions. The only difference

RE: Scope of the House of Justice -VERY LONG

2005-01-30 Thread Susan Maneck
Considering that I wasn't stating my opinion and and defining my personal logic in an attempt to persuade, I would have to say No to your question. I don't view this as a great debate with a winner and loser. Dear Sandra, Sorry if I came down too hard in that last post. I'm using the term

Re: Scope of the House of Justice -VERY LONG

2005-01-30 Thread howard green
Dr. G. Thanks, the unsubscribe request went through From: "Richard H. Gravelly" [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: "Baha'i Studies" bahai-st@list.jccc.edu To: "Baha'i Studies" bahai-st@list.jccc.edu Subject: Re: Scope of the House of Justice -VERY LONG Date: S

RE: Scope of the House of Justice -VERY LONG

2005-01-29 Thread Susan Maneck
I'm in complete agreement with Brent's understanding and I feel that is supported by numerous references from Baha'u'llah's Writings where the *Trustees* are a direct reference the the [Universal] House of Justice. Dear Sandra, Some of those passage you cite would refer only to the Universal

Re: Scope of the House of Justice -VERY LONG

2005-01-29 Thread Sandra Chamberlain
Susan: Some of those passage you cite would refer only to the Universal House of Justice and some to Houses of Justice in general. I don't think that the term 'trustee' is any hint as to which He is referring to. All members of any elected institution are 'Trustees of the Merciful.' Dear

Re: Scope of the House of Justice -VERY LONG

2005-01-29 Thread Smaneck
In a message dated 1/29/2005 6:55:36 P.M. Central Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: "Now, if I were not aware of the Guardian's persnickety precision in his English translations, I might agree that all the previous post references referred to any Baha'i House of Justice.