Re: [DISCUSS] Donating easy-cass-stress to the project

2024-05-03 Thread Alexander DEJANOVSKI
Hi folks, I'm familiar with the codebase and can help with the maintenance and evolution. I already have some additional profiles that I can push there which were never merged in the main branch of tlp-cluster. I love this tool (I know I'm biased) and hope it gets the attention it deserves. Le

Re: [DISCUSS] Donating easy-cass-stress to the project

2024-04-30 Thread Jordan West
I would likely commit to it as well Jordan On Mon, Apr 29, 2024 at 10:55 David Capwell wrote: > So: besides Jon, who in the community expects/desires to maintain this > going forward? > > > I have been maintaining a fork for years, so don’t mind helping maintain > this project. > > On Apr 28,

Re: [DISCUSS] Donating easy-cass-stress to the project

2024-04-29 Thread David Capwell
> So: besides Jon, who in the community expects/desires to maintain this going > forward? I have been maintaining a fork for years, so don’t mind helping maintain this project. > On Apr 28, 2024, at 4:08 AM, Mick Semb Wever wrote: > >> A separate subproject like dtest and the Java driver

Re: [DISCUSS] Donating easy-cass-stress to the project

2024-04-28 Thread Mick Semb Wever
> > A separate subproject like dtest and the Java driver would maybe help > address concerns with introducing a gradle build system and Kotlin. > Nit, dtest is a separate repository, not a subproject. The Java driver is one repository to be in the Drivers subproject. Esoteric maybe, but ASF

Re: [DISCUSS] Donating easy-cass-stress to the project

2024-04-27 Thread Brad
The current cassandra-stress is in poor condition and clocks in at a hefty 16k lines of Java code. I was involved in some work with it last Summer (CASSANDRA-18529) and it was tricky. I'm strongly in favor of replacing it with a modern tool which is easier to configure and more user friendly.

Re: [DISCUSS] Donating easy-cass-stress to the project

2024-04-26 Thread Jon Haddad
@mck I haven't done anything with IP clearance. Not sure how to, and I want to get a feel for if we even want it in the project before I invest time in. Jeff's question about people willing to maintain the project is a good one and if people aren't willing to maintain it with me, it's only going

Re: [DISCUSS] Donating easy-cass-stress to the project

2024-04-26 Thread Mick Semb Wever
On Fri, 26 Apr 2024 at 00:11, Jon Haddad wrote: > I should probably have noted - since TLP is no more, I renamed tlp-stress > to easy-cass-stress around half a year ago when I took it over again. > Do we have the IP cleared for donation ? At what SHA did you take and rename tlp-stress, and who

Re: [DISCUSS] Donating easy-cass-stress to the project

2024-04-25 Thread Caleb Rackliffe
I do have some familiarity w/ the codebase, and I could help support it in a minor capacity. (Reviews, small fixes, etc.) Probably not something I could spend hours on every week.On Apr 25, 2024, at 5:11 PM, Jon Haddad wrote:I should probably have noted - since TLP is no more, I renamed

Re: [DISCUSS] Donating easy-cass-stress to the project

2024-04-25 Thread Jon Haddad
I should probably have noted - since TLP is no more, I renamed tlp-stress to easy-cass-stress around half a year ago when I took it over again. Jon On Thu, Apr 25, 2024 at 3:05 PM Jeff Jirsa wrote: > Unless there’s 2-3 other people who expect to keep working on it, I don’t > see how we justify

Re: [DISCUSS] Donating easy-cass-stress to the project

2024-04-25 Thread Jeff Jirsa
Unless there’s 2-3 other people who expect to keep working on it, I don’t see how we justify creating a subprojectAnd if there’s not 2-3 people expressing interest, even pulling it into the main project seems riskySo: besides Jon, who in the community expects/desires to maintain this going

Re: [DISCUSS] Donating easy-cass-stress to the project

2024-04-25 Thread Dinesh Joshi
I am not familiar with ECS but if we’re going to go for it I would prefer it to be a sub project really. Jon, what do you think? On Thu, Apr 25, 2024 at 2:44 PM Brandon Williams wrote: > I want to begin by saying I am generally +1 on this because I have > become a fan of easy-cass-stress after

Re: [DISCUSS] Donating easy-cass-stress to the project

2024-04-25 Thread Jon Haddad
Yeah, I agree with your concerns. I very firmly prefer a separate subproject. I've got zero interest in moving from a modern Gradle project to an ant based one. It would be a lot of work for not much benefit. If we wanted to replace cassandra-stress, I'd say bring in the release artifact as

Re: [DISCUSS] Donating easy-cass-stress to the project

2024-04-25 Thread Brandon Williams
I want to begin by saying I am generally +1 on this because I have become a fan of easy-cass-stress after using it, but I am curious if this is intended to be a subproject, or replace cassandra-stress? If the latter, we are going to have to reconcile the build systems somehow. I don't really

[DISCUSS] Donating easy-cass-stress to the project

2024-04-25 Thread Jon Haddad
I've been asked by quite a few people, both in person and in JIRA [1] about contributing easy-cass-stress [2] to the project. I've been happy to maintain the project myself over the years but given its widespread use I think it makes sense to make it more widely available and under the project's