Moshe,
I don't mean to be rude here- but it may help you to follow some of the PSYCHE-D discussions on the Zombie argument. Their structure may help you to unravel some of your philosophical dead-ends. I don't mean to suggest that we don't all create them for our selves whentrying to study the mind and various types of cognitive systems. You may alos be interested in reading Daniel Dennett's argument on Ned Blocks' "On being a Bat" - you'll find that in Dennett's Consciousness Explained. (Yep- pretty arrogant title)
Personally I am of the opinion that it is always a disappointing scientific pursuit to speak about 'intelligence' in and of itself - or even compared with other species. Or to prove that various character or personality traits are indicative of its presence or absence. For example- saying that two agents have an IQ of 160 are equally intelligent is really a silly statement. And correlations are merely that- correlations.What we as scientists should be more interested in are causal dynamics. The structure and functions that interplay to allow for behaviour to appear intelligent. And in all of this we really are caught in evolution's stranglehold - because we only 'see' what works. I think it was either von Galsersfeld or Leo Apostel who claimed that "The environment is held for extinction". What ever is not selected for is selected out. So, we have only our postulates.
In terms of the role of emotions in contributing towards reasoning, you may wish to do some serious neuropsyche reading. You could follow Le Douz, Damasio and that bunch just as a start. I don't mean this to be rude- it's just a very old and rather precarious Descartesian supposition that you refer to when you discuss the role of emotions and the 'extent' to which they contribute to reason. That's the same mad-making question as trying to figure out exactly how much of the visual cortex is involved when we do math, for e.g.
You allude to the need to integrate some "theories of behaviour": Crikey Moshe! This stunned me! Haven't you heard of Psychology, Sociology, Political theory, history, theology etc etc... they all give Theories of Behaviour.
In terms of an Ethics I would popose that it behoves us to respect other forms of intelligence. Different is important. We surplant our own brand of brain with lots of devices. But we still haven't invented one that can smell better than a dog can. An interesting study was conducted with genetically identical twins who were put on the same diet for 3 days. one twin was then asked to sleep in a T-shirt. The researchers conducted this study with at least 3 different sets of twins. On each and every single occasion the sniffer dogs found the correct GENETICALLY identical twin - i.e. the one who had slept in the T-shirt. Scent is supposed to be genetically determined. As far as I know this study is still under discussion.
OK- my last comment before I get hacked: You will have a tough time convincing linguistists, philosophers, cognitive scientists inter alia that you can very VERY clearly separate language from associative learning.
But perhaps I didn't get what you REALLY mean?
Margeret
Brad wrote:
> It might be easier to build a human intelligence than a dog
intelligence simply
> because we don't have a dog's perspective and we can't ask them to
reflect on it.
> Don't be quick to assume it would be easier just because they are less
intelligent.
Kevin wrote:
> planning an intercept trajectory
> balance of the leap
> understanding body momentum
> understanding and using gravity
> control of hundreds of muscles
> ...
The point is not to pass a dog-turing-test, the point is to try and
abstract important features of intelligence that dogs, cats, chimps, and
humans all possess. So I don't want to put up "dog specific" list items
like "mark territory with urine", even though this arguably is part of
doggie-smarts ;->. What I'm really looking for are things that a dog,
stephen hawking, and helen keller all have. In the next update of the
article, I'll definitely add
a disclaimer to this effect..
Philip wrote:
> Dogs are social animals that live in packs (often). There's nothing
on
> the list about social behaviours.
Good point. It has been argued that intelligence is correlated with
group size, and this should not be dismissed lightly. However, I think
that there are fairly intelligent animals that don't engage in _very
much_ socialization (e.g., leopards, hackers ;->). I did put on the
list, "Imitation: recognizing that other entities are 'like myself'
(arguably a weak form of consciousness), and that the things that they
do are similar to the things I do, and trying to do some of the things
they do." which is a kind of social behavior. This should probably be
expanded to encompas "theories of behavior" e.g., a theory of how sheep
behave, a theory of how humans behave, etc..
Philip also wrote:
> Dogs are curious, they play, they have language skills - especially i
n
> terms of understanding what humans say
I think this is associative learning, rather that language.
Philip also also wrote:
> They can care for litters of 10 or so pups and they don't lose them so
they must
> have numeracy skills or some way of identifying which of the pups is
missing.
This is an important point that I hadn't considered. I'm not sure
offhand whether dogs possess "numeracy" of the sort that this would seem
to indicate, and if so, how it is produced. I'll have to do some
thinking...
> They've got a huge range of emotions - anger, joyfulness, curiosity,
> empathy, protectiveness, caring, fear, loneliness, aggression,
> dominance.
Its debatable to what extent emotions actually contribute to
intelligence ;->. Again, I'll have to think about this...
Thanks for all the constructive feedback!
Cheers,
Moshe
-------
To unsubscribe, change your
address, or temporarily deactivate your subscription,
please go to http://v2.listbox.com/member/[EMAIL PROTECTED]
With Yahoo! Mail you can get a bigger mailbox -- choose a size that fits your needs
