On Mon, 2010-08-16 at 20:08 -0400, Geoffrey Spear wrote: > NUM C I AI SUBMITTER TITLE I vote as follows: > 6790 R 1 2.0 Wooble Assumption Makes This Unnecessary FOR > 6791 P 1 1.0 omd Contestification FOR, although you need to clean up the appropriate Ribbon > 6792 P 1 2.0 omd Contests FOR; we need this so badly that I don't even particularly care if you've snuck a scam into this somehow > 6793 R 1 2.0 Wooble shorter speedup counterproposal FOR, I like it. > 6794 P 0 1.0 coppro Restore White Conditional: AGAINST if proposal 6794 passes/would pass, FOR otherwise > 6795 P 0 1.0 coppro Repair White FOR > 6796 P 1 2.0 coppro The Robot AGAINST > 6797 P 0 1.0 omd More clarification FOR > 6798 P 1 1.0 coppro Bitrot PRESENT > 6799 G 0 1.0 Keba Win by Respect FOR, this particular set of boilerplate is nicer than the current one, and has better behaviour in edge cases > 6800 P 1 1.5 coppro Distribution FOR > 6801 R 0 1.0 Wooble No One Wants To Do It PRESENT > 6802 G 1 1.0 Murphy Yoink! PRESENT; I'm not sure what we gain from this, if anything, and the ruleset's getting a bit crufty > 6803 G 0 1.0 Murphy Low altitude Endorse the PSM; a weekly report makes it easier for the PSM to figure out current prop standings if the ATC isn't online at the time > 6804 G 1 2.0 Murphy Energize new players FOR > 6805 G 1 1.0 Keba Props should be important! AGAINST; looks rather tricky to track, and will encourage people to transfer props with all sorts of frivolous reasons. If nothing else, this is really unfair to inactive players, who will be drained to 0 props merely due to not paying attention to the mailing lists. In general, a "you-must-do-this-every-week" grind in Agora is a bad idea. > 6806 P 1 3.1 coppro Ratification misstep FOR; what /is/ it with ratifying the rules that we keep screwing up every single time? > 6807 P 1 3.0 coppro Complete Induction AGAINST; potentially too vague, and looks like a scam magnet > 6808 P 1 1.0 coppro Super Robot Powers AGAINST > 6809 P 1 3.0 omd OK Go AGAINST; proposals in a large distribution is one of Agora's biggest strengths, and I much prefer Wooble's solution above. I rarely vote as it is; if proposals weren't bundled into distributions, I doubt I'd vote at all except as part of a scam. > 6810 P 1 2.0 omd Make erg accumulation somewhat easier PRESENT; incidentally, as there's no reason not to do this last thing on Sunday, why not just make it automatic?
-- ais523
