Such a CFJ does not exist, as the message calling for judgment was never
sent to a public forum.
Jason Cobb
On 6/4/19 4:08 PM, Aris Merchant wrote:
Your assurance that you are not committed to a certain outcome is
enough, I think.
The CFJ with the statement "If no player activates Rule 2596 'The
Ritual' in a certain week, all players playing the game that week have
violated the rule, which provides that (1) "Any player CAN perform The
Ritual" and (2) "The Ritual MUST be performed at least once in every
Agoran week." is CFJ 3730. I assign it to D. Margaux.
On Tue, Jun 4, 2019 at 12:35 PM D Margaux <[email protected]> wrote:
From the beginning, this issue was always going to become a CFJ. I’m not an
interested party in the outcome, in the sense that the decision doesn’t give me
any particular benefit in the game. And the caller of the CFJ isn’t appealing
my reasoning, but instead agrees with it.
I did give my tentative views on the subject, but I pledge to re-evaluate the
issue in good faith in light of the arguments that have been raised if I am
assigned this CFJ. I don’t have any commitment to any particular result,
except that I thought it was the correctly reasoned one, but I remain open to
being persuaded otherwise. (That’s partly why I labeled my prior email a
proto, rather than an actual decision on the pointed finger.)
