On Tuesday, May 19, 2020 6:54:22 PM CDT Kerim Aydin via agora-official wrote: > I love that this whole argument is moot: > > - The practical issue has self-ratified since the judgement, so is moot. > > - The arguments are so specific to a certain sort of ambiguity that > there's likely no applicable precedent, so are moot. > > - The judge, who would remain the judge upon remand, is no even longer a > player, so eir opinion is moot. > > - Conclusion: Moot is a lovely word: moot, moot, moot, moot, moot. > > > I hereby initiate an Agoran Decision to determine public confidence in CFJ > 3831's current judgement of FALSE, delivered by Alexis on 26 Apr 2020 > (that is, a Moot). > > Case at: https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/?3831, also > included in full below. > > For this decision: > vote collector: Arbitor > quorum: 5 > voting method: first-past-the-post > valid options: AFFIRM, REMAND, and REMIT (PRESENT is also a valid vote, > as are conditional votes). > > > [Editorial: It's very likely that REMAND will just delay the case until > Alexis can be recused a week later.] > > Have fun mooting!
I vote endorse G. -- nch
