On Sat, 14 Feb 2009, Kerim Aydin wrote: > This morning, I find myself more swayed by pro- than anti-. That > changes each time I think about it. The only thing I'm *sure* of is > that I think a judge needs to come right out and say they are weighing > these closely-balanced sides on the interest of the game, and perhaps, as > much as anything, commit emself to a subjective opinion rather than > looking for a final piece of hard logic.
I should also say that now that the dictatorship has ended one way or the other, and voting on proposals to fix the bugs are in progress, making a "good of the game" argument solely based on "it's not for the good of the game for comex to have a power-3 dictatorship" seems like Bad Form. -Goethe
