On Mon, Apr 26, 2010 at 08:07, ais523 <callforjudgem...@yahoo.co.uk> wrote: > On Mon, 2010-04-26 at 08:52 -0400, Geoffrey Spear wrote: >> On Sun, Apr 25, 2010 at 9:51 PM, Aaron Goldfein <aarongoldf...@gmail.com> >> wrote: >> > Registrar's Census >> >> > FIRST-CLASS PLAYERS (19) >> > >> > Nickname E-mail address Since Status >> > ------------------------------------------------------------------- >> > ais523 ais...@bham.ac.uk 28 Apr 08 SA >> > allispaul allisp...@gmail.com 26 Feb 10 A >> > Andon aoz...@gmail.com 01 Mar 10 A >> > BobTHJ pidge...@gmail.com 17 Jan 08 S >> > comex com...@gmail.com 01 May 07 SA >> > coppro ride...@gmail.com 07 Mar 09 SA >> > ehird penguinoftheg...@googlemail.com 26 Feb 09 S >> > Epaeris hermitchipm...@gmail.com 18 Apr 10 A >> > G. ke...@u.washington.edu 31 Oct 09 SA >> > Ienpw III james.m.bei...@gmail.com 04 Aug 09 S >> > Murphy emurph...@socal.rr.com 27 Oct 07 SA >> > Phoenix benuphoen...@gmail.com 17 Dec 09 S >> > Sgeo sgeos...@gmail.com 27 Jun 08 S >> > Spitemaster benner...@gmail.com 08 Mar 10 A >> > Taral tar...@gmail.com 28 Apr 07 S >> > Tiger jonatan.kilh...@gmail.com 04 Feb 09 SA >> > Warrigal ihope12...@gmail.com 21 Sep 09 SA >> > woggle woggl...@gmail.com 05 Mar 10 A >> > Yally aarongoldf...@gmail.com 07 Feb 09 SA >> [...] >> > Left in 2010: >> > >> > d Normish Partnership 2 r...@normish.org 12 Aug 08 17 Jan 10 >> > a Darth Cliche kenner...@gmail.com 22 Sep 09 26 Jan 10 >> > a Quazie quazieno...@gmail.com 27 Apr 09 26 Jan 10 >> > a woggle woggl...@gmail.com 23 Dec 07 26 Jan 10 >> > v Wooble geoffsp...@gmail.com 17 Nov 09 30 Jan 10 >> > v Walker charles.w.wal...@googlemail.com 05 Dec 09 30 Jan 10 >> > d IBA c/o comex? 21 Aug 09 02 Mar 10 >> > v Pavitra celestialcognit...@gmail.com 25 Jan 08 14 Apr 10 >> > >> >> CoE: This report neither lists me as a player nor lists the purported >> deregistration that would have needed to have occurred were I not a >> player. It is either an incorrect self-ratifying statement that I'm >> not a player, or an ILLEGAL report violating R2139's requirement to >> include the dates on which I registered and deregistered (in which >> case I lack the standing to make both this then-incorrect CoE and to >> publish an NoV.) > > Per the above evidence (and acting on Wooble/Annabel's request; I'll use > the name "Wooble" in this message, as it's the name that should have > been listed in the report), I NoV against Yally for violating the > power-1 rule 2143 by either publishing inaccurate or misleading > information about Wooble's registration status, or failing to publish > full information about Wooble's registration history. (Luckily, both > these are violations of the same rule, so I don't need to know which > occurred; it seems reasonably obvious that at least one of them did, > given that Wooble's reregistration on March 21 2010 is as far as I know > uncontested, but unlisted in the report.) > > Evidence: > On Sun, 21 Mar 2010 21:35:56 -0400, Wooble wrote: >> On Sun, Mar 21, 2010 at 6:03 PM, Sean Hunt <ride...@gmail.com> wrote: >> > I intend, without 2 objections, to set the Interest Index of the >> Registrar >> > office to 0. >> >> I register. I object. >> >> --Wooble >> > > -- > ais523
A simple CoE would have sufficed. I don't see a particular need for excessive punishment for an honest mistake during an extremely busy time for me.
