On Sun, May 19, 2013 at 7:16 PM, Kerim Aydin <ke...@u.washington.edu> wrote:
> > > [My apologies if this was done before and I missed it!] > > > I submit the following Promise, 'DOA', to the Tree: > > Text: Hello, World. > Conditions for Cashing: There is a copy (i.e. fungible instance) > of this Promise in possession of the tree. > > > I CFJ on: Wes CAN transfer the DOA promise to emself. > > Arguments: > Rule 2338 reads "If a promise is possessed by the Tree, any > player except the promise's author CAN transfer it to emself by > announcement, if e cashes the promise in the same message in > which e transfers it to emself." > Arguments: FALSE, because Rule 2339 does not say anything about whether the promise in question can be cashed while it is in the Tree's possession. The legality of a transfer is determined only by whether or not the promise is later cashed; thus, since it would be impossible for Wes to cash DOA while possessing it, it cascades and transferring DOA from the Tree is impossible. -scshunt
