V.J Rada wrote: > I also point the finger at gaelan for being late on two CFJs and the SLR > (twice, I think)
These would be CFJs 3520 and 3521, both assigned on June 6th, 2017: 14 days prior to the Finger-Pointing above. Rule 591 (“Delivering Judgements”) states, in part: > When a CFJ is open and assigned to a judge, that judge CAN assign a valid > judgement to it by announcement, and SHALL do so in a timely fashion after > this becomes possible. Rule 1023 (“Common Definitions”) defines “in a timely fashion” as follows: > The phrase "in a timely fashion" means "within 7 days”. This time period is > set when the requirement is created (i.e. X daysbefore the limit ends). Reviewing the open CFJs, it appears to be possible to assign a judgement to each of them as of the date they were assigned. As it has been more than seven days since those CFJs were assigned, Gaelan has violated the SHALL clause cited above from r. 591. The subject matter of the two CFJs in question is of extremely limited impact on the overall scope of the game. Each addresses questions about the relationship between a proposal and some other entity. Neither the text nor the adoption index nor the title of the proposal are in question, and the facts that are in question are of little long-term significance. I issue Gaelan a Green Card by summary judgement. The Short Logical Ruleset (“SLR”) is part of the Rulekeepor’s report, defined in r. 1051 (“The Rulekeepor”): > The Rulekeepor's Weekly report includes the Short Logical Ruleset. Rule 2143 (“Official Reports and Duties”) governs the frequency with which weekly reports must be issued: > If any task is defined by the rules as part of that person's weekly duties, > then e SHALL perform it at least once each week. If any information is > defined by the rules as part of that person's weekly report, then e SHALL > maintain all such information, and the publication of all such information is > part of eir weekly duties. Gaelan is the incumbent Rulekeepor, and last published the Short Logical Ruleset on May 28th. E has not performed this portion of eir weekly duties in well over a week. This infraction has the potential to be more serious, as the regular publication of the SLR is crucial to ensuring that players may maintain an accurate understanding of the current Rules without having to track each proposal by hand. However, in mitigation, Gaelan has done excellent work publishing and maintaining an unofficial repository of the Rules at <https://agoranomic.org/ruleset/>. E has also been steadfast in publishing the monthly Full Logical Ruleset, although the deadline for doing so this month is appraoching quickly. On the balance, I find that the effect of Gaelan’s omission is minor and of little consequence at this time, and does not merit significant censure. I award Gaelan a Green Card by summary judgement. -o
signature.asc
Description: Message signed with OpenPGP
