On 8/28/26 1:07 AM, Janet Cobb via agora-business wrote:
Now consider how this affects whether the decision can be resolved. R208
requires that, when resolving an Agoran decision, the vote provider
provide "a tally of the voters' valid ballots". In current game custom,
for an AI-majority decision, this is considered to require a tally of
the votes after resolving conditional votes (i.e. all FOR, AGAINST, or
PRESENT). (The Assessor has not, for the past several years, published
the full text of any conditional ballots received. Reading the rule to
require this almost certainly loses a $217 tiebreak.) Since my fully
resolved vote is indeterminate, I argue that whether meeting this
requirement is possible is PARADOXICAL (and thus so is CFJ 4162).
"Tally" isn't otherwise defined, so why couldn't it be a count of FOR,
AGAINST, PRESENT, and "other" (or some such category)?
Regardless, I don't see why this results in a PARADOXICAL outcome. If the
tally must be FOR/AGAINST/PRESENT and no other format, then you simply can't
resolve it. If it can be more flexible than that (e.g., we've implicitly had
zero "other" votes in tallies to date), then you can resolve it.
Finally, for CFJ 4163, the Assessor, in attempting to discharge eir duty
to resolve the referendum on P9371, attempted to resolve it while
counting my vote as PRESENT [1]. As this depends on whether my vote
evaluates to PRESENT, I argue that CFJ 4163 should be PARADOXICAL for
the same reasons as CFJ 4162.
Likewise, either you can or you can't.
Also, by your arguments, wouldn't any vote where there's been a cycle of
endorsements (knowing Agora there's probably been at least one such
instance) currently be unresolved?
--
Mischief
Collar, Collector, Executor
Hat: steampunk hat