On Fri, Aug 28, 2026, 12:08 AM Janet Cobb via agora-business <
[email protected]> wrote:
> As for CFJ 4161, I argue for TRUE. As for CFJ 4162, I argue for
> PARADOXICAL. As for CFJ 4163, I argue for PARADOXICAL.
>
> The vote in question (from [0]) is my vote on the referendum on Proposal
> 9371, which is as follows:
>
> {
>
> If the current year in UTC is 2026, this conditional vote evaluates to
> this conditional vote.
>
> Otherwise, this conditional vote evaluates to FOR.
>
> }
>
> First, this is a valid vote. R2528 defines "valid votes" to include "the
> valid conditional votes, as defined by rules of power at least [3]".
> R2127 (of power 3) defines as a "valid conditional vote" "[a]ny vote
> which is clearly expressed as a conditional". My vote clearly meets this
> requirement: it selects between two votes based on a condition (whether
> the UTC year is 2026), and all elements of the vote are clear.
>
> (The first paragraph says that a conditional vote is "a vote which
> indicates a vote based on some condition(s)". To refute any argument
> that this causes my vote to not be a "conditional vote", note that this
> definition nowhere requires the any involved vote to be "valid". In
> fact, "vote" is never defined anywhere (only "valid vote" is), so "vote"
> falls through to its natural language meaning. And, regardless, the
> later definition of "valid conditional vote" takes precedence over this
> definition of "conditional vote".)
>
> This should make CFJ 4161 TRUE.
>
> Next, note that Rule 2127 defines that this vote is "clearly specified
> if and only if the value of the condition(s) is/are determinate at the
> end of the voting period". The sole "condition" in this vote is whether
> "the current year in UTC is 2026". This is clearly determinate (and
> true). The vote is thus clearly specified. (Note that this does *not*
> require that the ultimate evaluation of the vote must be determinate.)
>
I think it actually does require determinate ultimate evaluation, in this
case. The conditions of a recursive vote include all of the circumstances
that result from recursion.
There is a difference betweeen "FOR if [x], AGAINST otherwise" and this
kind of vote. Rather, this is "[y] if [x], FOR otherwise". Y brings in the
conditions of infinite other y's and x's, and seeing as at the time of
evaluation y's value is indeterminate (it is constantly being reevaluated),
the vote is NOT clearly specified.
Thus CFJ 4162 and 4163 should be judged TRUE.
>
--
snail
Steampunk Hat