Galle wrote:

On Aug 29, 2026, at 1:44 PM, msh210 via agora-business 
<[email protected]> wrote:

I call for judgement on "The message quoted above was a public
message.", barring Ronic.  I have no argument for TRUE or FALSE;
indeed, I believe it is currently INSUFFICIENT.

I intend to deputize for the Arbitor to number and assign this CFJ. I also 
confirm that I did in fact receive Ronic's message.

So did I, but I suggest DISMISS on the grounds that:

  * Verifying the full list of bcc recipients would require unreasonable
    effort (confirmation from all players, including inactive ones).

  * While I confirmed that the full list of cc recipients matched all
    addresses in the latest Registrar's weekly report (plus Ronic
    emself), and have no particular reason to doubt their word, I don't
    think we should set a precedent for treating "I bcc'd all players,
    evidence: just trust me bro" as generally being sufficient evidence;
    that seems like it would encourage Not Fun scam attempts.

--
[ANSC H:GE]

Reply via email to