Galle wrote:

On 8/30/2026 3:42 PM, Gregory Hayes via agora-discussion wrote:
On Aug 30, 2026, at 4:15 PM, Edward Murphy via agora-discussion 
<[email protected]> wrote:

So did I, but I suggest DISMISS on the grounds that:

  * Verifying the full list of bcc recipients would require unreasonable
    effort (confirmation from all players, including inactive ones).

  * While I confirmed that the full list of cc recipients matched all
    addresses in the latest Registrar's weekly report (plus Ronic
    emself), and have no particular reason to doubt their word, I don't
    think we should set a precedent for treating "I bcc'd all players,
    evidence: just trust me bro" as generally being sufficient evidence;
    that seems like it would encourage Not Fun scam attempts.

--
[ANSC H:GE]

I can see the logic behind this, but it is in fact rather important to know 
whether Ronic actually successfully published the message. Eir registration 
status depends on it, as does the existence of a proposal.

Only the exact timing of eir registration (within about five hours)
should depend on it. E later sent a message to Gio + cc'd to all
players, which was unambiguously effective if the bcc'd one wasn't.

Also, dismissing the CFJ would arguably set an equally bad precedent. If we can 
never know that a message was sent to all players unless we manually confirm 
with each player that e received the message in question, including players 
that are inactive, then it's essentially impossible to EVER know whether a 
message was published this way. The ability to send messages whose publicity is 
impossible to determine could lead to, quite frankly, even less fun scam 
attempts.

This is only an argument against specifically bcc'ing. The "all
players" method just requires "sent to all players and containing a
clear designation of intent to be public"; it doesn't require that
all players receive it, and "all players appear in To: and/or Cc:"
+ "some other players respond to it" should be sufficient.

--
[ANSC H:GE]

Reply via email to