I'm no expert on these topics, but I'll give my honest opinions where I have notes. Everything before the !!! is more on the mechanical side, everything after is more conceptual.


First off, I agree with kiako that "Markov Blanket" is not very clear.

On 9/1/2026 7:57 PM, Matt Smyth via agora-discussion wrote:

       The basis of a Real Person is the specific physical organism and
       the primary physical communication node (such as an email address
       or forum account) used by em to interact with the game. Rules to
       the contrary notwithstanding, a Real Person CANNOT become Registered
       if eir basis overlaps with that of three (3) or more current players.

3 here feels arbitrary. Maybe it would be a better idea to require an increasing number of Co-Signers, perhaps exponentially so, or require an AI-majority Agoran decision with an increasing AI, but also barring those sharing a basis with the Real Person in question (though this would require some extra framework)? It just feels like having a hardcap with a topic of this nature isn't the best idea.

       If two or more Players Object, the registration
       is suspended, and the Registrar MUST immediately initiate an expedited
       in-game vote. If a simple majority of voters find the registration to
       be a bad-faith sockpuppet account, the registration is declared
       permanently VOID.

While I can fairly clearly see the intent, "immediately" and "permanently VOID" are not defined by the rules.


       If multiple Real People sharing a partial or identical basis are
       registered as separate players, their individual votes on any given
       matter are scaled proportionally such that the absolute sum of their
       voting weights combined cannot exceed 1.5.

"Voting weight" is also never defined in the rules, so this doesn't work. !!! Also, I'm not sure about the motivation behind this part, given that each player is an individual with eir own ideas and opinions.

I have no problems with the remainder of the draft, so the rest of this email will be dedicated to elaborating on the last point, and more general implications of plurality in Agora.

Imagine a tightly-knit friend group of 4 or more who spend every day together. They decide they all want to join Agora as different players, and they can do so as long as they have 4 separate E-mail accounts, with the full voting power of all of them. They discuss actions together, oftentimes having similar opinions, and work together to achieve shared goals, and when they disagree, being friends does not affect their impact on Agora.

Now imagine a system with 4 or more members, just about equal in relationship as the friend group was, the only difference being only one organism. Under this draft, it would be impossible for all of them to be players, and only one could until an existing player could be convinced to co-sign. Even if that did happen, each of them would then be subject to a 50% (1-[1.5/3]) reduction to voting strength, regardless of their actual opinions. (Again, I am no expert in this topic, ((I see why gender studies is a thing now.)) so know this is a hypothetical not meant to represent any system in particular, and I sincerely apologize if this is misrepresenting plurality as a whole.)

Therefore, the question is twofold.

1. Should the players in the friend group be treated differently from a player unconnected from any other, and if so, how?

2. Should the players in the system be treated differently from the players in the friend group, and if so, how?

My answers to these are as follows:

1. I don't think there is a way to implement such a mechanism in a reasonably private manner.

2. Personally, I don't think so at all, though your opinions may differ.

Sorry if this message is a bit political.


--
pizza723
Notary for Agora Nomic


--
This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
www.avg.com

Reply via email to