kiako wrote:

>Could you define (or site a definition of) "cognitive Markov blanket" as it 
>applies to this proposal? Cross-referenced a few papers briefly, but none 
>immediately stands out as what you're >referring to.

Yeah, sure. I reference
https://royalsocietypublishing.org/rsif/article/15/138/20170792/35768/The-Markov-blankets-of-life-autonomy-active
as a useful tool, but, in simple English, a Markov blanket is a
boundary that is defined by three things -
1. An Inside (namely, a private space for internal processes)
2. A Filter (the ability to process its own sensory inputs, regardless
of whether or not that ability is used)
3. Control (the ability to generate independent actions)
So, a biological cell has a Markov blanket, since it has a clear
internal chemistry separate from the external fluids, receptors that
observe the outside states and change actions based on it, and the
ability to do so - even if, most of the time, the cell is controlled
by an organ. I do see that I've worded my proposal poorly, though. I
would have to replace the paragraph with

     A Markov Blanket is defined as a boundary that establishes
     the capabilities of Inside (private internal states),
     Filter (sensory inputs), and Control (active outputs),
     regardless of whether or not those capabilities are accessed.

      Any entity that possesses a distinct cognitive Markov blanket
      is known as a Distinct Person. An entity is NOT a Distinct
      Person if its game actions are determined by the direct
      operational control of another Player or external software script.

------
pizza723 wrote:

>3 here feels arbitrary. Maybe it would be a better idea to require an
>increasing number of Co-Signers, perhaps exponentially so, or require an
>AI-majority Agoran decision with an increasing AI, but also barring
>those sharing a basis with the Real Person in question (though this
>would require some extra framework)? It just feels like having a hardcap
>with a topic of this nature isn't the best idea.

Fair. I essentially wanted to make it more clear within the ruleset
that "People" count as independent mental entities rather than a basis
of physicality. However, I pre-empted the criticisms of "If you allow
as many separate headmates to join as needed, what stops a bad-faith
singlet from just 'having' 100 headmates and multiplying income and
votes by 100?" by limiting headmates to three. I mean, yeah, I think
it's kind of discriminatory. And, as a literal system drafting a
system-discriminatory rule, I accept the criticism, but I think on the
balance of things, it's better to have some headmates than none.

>Also, I'm not sure about the motivation behind this part,
>given that each player is an individual with eir own ideas and opinions.

Again - a singlet could be like, "Hey! How come they get 3x the
votes?" and be kind of pluralphobic, and I accept that I probably
overstepped by treating systems as distinct from distinct individuals.
--------------
Tl;dr - valid points, I was overcorrecting, I'll remove the hardcap on
membership and voting, and make it clearer what the boundaries of a
person are. I'll put the proposal to the promotor on 9 September
unless any other major flaws are mentioned.

--
juniper

Reply via email to