On Thu, Sep 3, 2026 at 6:00 AM juan via agora-discussion < [email protected]> wrote:
> Hi, I'll give my 2 cents. > > kiako via agora-discussion [2026-09-01 12:02]: > > Hi all, > > > > Given the 3(?) recent cases in Agora of LLMs being employed by players > > (automated and otherwise), the Discord's been discussing if we need a > > clear stance on LLMs and "agents" in Agora. To keep the conversation > > archived & accessible, I'm moving it to the list. > > > > I'd appreciate if those with vested interest in Agora could chip in > > their opinions. > > As a side note: I don't know what a headmate is, and I feel like I'm out > of the discussion on “singlets” and whatever. To my mind, collective > player in Agora are persons only in a agoran-legal sense. Come on. People > (in the ordinary sense) are those entities that have sufficiently > complex/similar to ours subjective experience – so humans, other > animals, etc. We should care, in the meta-game, about the feelings > of those kinds of people that engage with the game, not the abstract > feelings of collectives (note that I include individuals in the basis > of a Person that do have feelings) [1]. > A plural system is an arrangement in which one human body identifies as a containing more than one person/sapient entity. [2] Headmate is one of the terms used for individuals within a plural system; like roommates, but for a body. The rule allowing for a collective to act as a person is primarily intended to allow a plural system or subset thereof to act as one player. The idea that it might be used by singlets (people outside of plural systems, who have only one person per body) who want to play together is more of a nice bonus. There is (one) historical precedent for this being done before personhood was well-defined, so it is a use-case that has interested people in the past. I don't want to out anyone, but I know for a fact that multiple plural systems have been involved in Agora at different times. I don't know conclusively know of any that have actually wanted to play as more than one player, although I have some reason to believe that it is possible that this has occurred in the past. I believe that the current rule has had some success in making plural systems feel welcomed and respected. > > Anyway, I would conclude by saying that we shouldn't regulate prematurely, > if no one is already offended by the happenings. Like, if someone is > getting triggered by the already-existing LLM presence, then let's engage > with the issue. But, if not, I would like to see things play out. Let's > have some mechanism ready to halt things if needed (remember, ultimately, > we have the Banned switch). Several players have mentioned on Discord that LLM related stuff may cause them to reduce their engagement in the game if not stopped. So this isn't a theoretical problem or borrowing trouble. [1]: If I'm being insensitive to someone, I will apologize, and do please > let me know. I don't see how anyone reasonable could be offended by a genuine lack of knowledge. [2] For more information, see https://morethanone.info/ -Aris >

