On 9/2/26 21:50, Kaia Sky via agora-discussion wrote:
> Obviously that can be changed (or it could be argued that while today's
> LLMs can pass the Turing test they are not "general AI"). I just want to
> illustrate that Agora's personhood rules seem shaped around the idea that,
> if and when nonhumans want to play Agora, they'll be welcome. At least in
> the abstract, I feel like that's a noble goal. I think it would be a little
> bit sad for the ruleset to have these broad all-encompassing definitions of
> personhood only to have them snap closed when something comes close to
> meeting those criteria. I also, admittedly, think it would be neat for
> Agora to have a nonhuman participant, if they could successfully
> participate in a constructive way.


I don't think what a lot of people have been suggesting here is
inconsistent with our definition of personhood. It's "we have determined
that this specific technology does not meet our criteria, and we find
using it to be harmful for these reasons, so please stop trying".
Regulating what *tools* people use when communicating with the lists
seems perfectly fine, and we've determined that LLMs are a tool. 

If the technology *were* to advance to such a point that it plausibly is
a person, I'd be happy to re-evaluate. Maybe my stance then would be to
change the definition to include "organic" or "human". I'm not sure.
Still, I certainly don't think proscribing their use *now* is reneging
on the promise we've made.

-- 
Janet Cobb

Assessor, Rulekeepor

Reply via email to