status: https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/#3504 (This document is informational only and contains no game actions).
============================== CFJ 3504 ============================== A player may award emself a White Ribbon. ======================================================================== Caller: Quazie Judge: ais523 Judgement: TRUE ======================================================================== History: Called by Quazie: 21 May 2017 Assiged to ais523: 21 May 2017 Judged TRUE by ais523: 21 May 2017 ======================================================================== Caller's Arguments: While rule 2438 states that 'While a person qualifies for a type of Ribbon, any player can generally award em that type of Ribbon.' I believe that the White Ribbon's text overrides that Generally, and that the only method of obtaining a White Ribbon is from another player. I submit as additional arguments: The below thread between nichdel and myself. On Sat, May 20, 2017 at 9:47 PM Nic Evans <nich...@gmail.com> wrote: Earlier in the rule it says "While a person qualifies for a type of Ribbon, any player can generally award em that type of Ribbon." Nothing says the mechanism specified by the White Ribbon is the only mechanism, and they're not contradictory mechanisms. In either case I still qualify for it, so I still get the Transparent. The only question is whether I receive the White. On 05/20/2017 11:44 PM, Quazie wrote: How does 'Can award another person' possibly mean 'can award emself'? On Sat, May 20, 2017 at 9:43 PM Nic Evans <nich...@gmail.com> wrote: I read the rule as having two mechanisms: 1 where you qualify by virtue of never having it, and therefore being able to award it, 2 where anyone can award it to anyone regardless of qualificaiton if they haven't before. Owen appears to have awarded emself a White ribbon previously: https://www.mail-archive.com/agora-business@agoranomic.org/msg28074.html On 05/20/2017 11:39 PM, Quazie wrote: You are not ANOTHER person, you can't award yourself a white ribbon. On Sat, May 20, 2017 at 9:38 PM Nic Evans <nich...@gmail.com> wrote: I have held the office of Assessor for >30 days, and in that time have never missed a deadline. I award myself the Green Ribbon. I assigned a judgment to CFJ 3499 [1] without missing any deadlines. I award myself a Blue Ribbon. I have been awarded the patent title Champion [2] in the last 7 days. I award myself an Ultraviolet Ribbon. I am the Speaker. I award myself a Platinum Ribbon. I have never had a White Ribbon. I award myself a White Ribbon. I have qualified for or earned 5 Ribbons [3] in the past 7 days. I award myself a Transparent Ribbon. [1] https://www.mail-archive.com/agora-business@agoranomic.org/msg28211.html [2] https://www.mail-archive.com/agora-official@agoranomic.org/msg07948.html [3] https://www.mail-archive.com/agora-business@agoranomic.org/msg28255.html ======================================================================== Caller's Evidence: Rule 2438/5 (Power=3) Ribbons The Tailor is an office, and the recordkeepor of Ribbons. Ribbon Ownership is a person switch, tracked by the Tailor in his monthly report, whose values are the subsets of the set of types of Ribbon, defaulting to the empty set. To "award a person a <Ribbon type>" is to add that type of Ribbon to that person's Ribbon Ownership. A person "owns a <Ribbon type>" if that type of Ribbon is an element of eir Ribbon Ownership. While a person qualifies for a type of Ribbon, any player can generally award em that type of Ribbon. A person qualifies for a type of Ribbon if e has earned that type of Ribbon within the preceding 7 days (including earlier in the same message) and has not owned that type of Ribbon within the preceding 7 days. While a person owns all types of Ribbon, that person can Raise a Banner by announcement. This causes that person to win the game. That person's Ribbon Ownership becomes the empty set. The types of Ribbon, and the methods of obtaining them, are as follows: Red (R): When a proposal is adopted and changes at least one rule with Power >= 3, its proposer earns a Red Ribbon. Orange (O): When a proposal is adopted via an Agoran Decision on which no valid votes were AGAINST, its proposer earns an Orange Ribbon. Green (G): While a person has held an elected office continuously for 30 days, and has not failed to perform any duties of that office within the appropriate time limits during those 30 days, that person qualifies for a Green Ribbon. Cyan (C): When a person deputises for an office, that person earns a Cyan Ribbon. Blue (B): When a person assigns a judgement to a CFJ, and has never violated a time limit to assign a judgement to that CFJ, that person earns a Blue Ribbon. Magenta (M): During Agora's Birthday, each person who has publicly acknowledged the fact qualifies for a Magenta Ribbon. Ultraviolet (U): When a person is awarded the Patent Title Champion, that person earns an Ultraviolet Ribbon. Violet (V): When a person is awarded a Patent Title other than Champion or a degree, that person earns a Violet Ribbon. Indigo (I): When a person is awarded a degree, that person earns an Indigo Ribbon. Platinum (P): The Speaker qualifies for a Platinum Ribbon. Lime (L): A person qualifies for a Lime Ribbon if three or more proposals adopted in the preceding 7 days had that person as a coauthor. White (W): A player qualifies for a White Ribbon if e has never previously owned a White Ribbon (including under previous rulesets). A player who has been registered for at least 30 days and has never caused another person to gain a White Ribbon (including under a previous ruleset) CAN award a White Ribbon to another person by announcement. Black (K): This rule does not specify any methods of obtaining Black Ribbons. Gray (A): The Tailor CAN award a Gray Ribbon by announcement, unless e has done so earlier in the month. E is ENCOURAGED to award such a Ribbon in the same message in which e publishes eir monthly report. Transparent (T): A person qualifies for a Transparent Ribbon while the number of other types of Ribbon that that person qualifies for and/or has earned within the previous 7 days is at least 5. ======================================================================== Judge's Arguments: There are two mechanisms for gaining a White Ribbon, the one in the fourth paragraph of rule 2438, and the one in the "White" paragraph of rule 2438. The former mechanism can be used by a player on emself. (In fact, it's usual for players to award emself White Ribbons via the former mechanism if they can; if a different player did it, e would lock emself out from using the latter mechanism in the future, and historically, the ability to award a White Ribbon to another has been a fairly valuable economic asset that players have traded a lot for.) ========================================================================