The below CFJ is 3749.  I assign it to Trigon.


===============================  CFJ 3749  ===============================

      The ordered list [Agora] is a valid vote in the ongoing ADoP
      election.

==========================================================================

Caller:                        Jason Cobb

Judge:                         Trigon

==========================================================================

History:

Called by Jason Cobb:                             01 Jul 2019 02:33:16
Assigned to Trigon:                               [now]

==========================================================================

Caller's Arguments:

CFJ 3746 has been resolved such that the Agoran Decision for the
election has a voting method of instant runoff. Therefore, by Rule 2528,
the valid votes include "the ordered lists of entities". [Agora] is an
ordered list of entities. Therefore, [Agora] is a valid vote in this
election.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Caller's Evidence:

Excerpt from Rule 2528 ("Voting Methods"):

    The valid votes on an Agoran decision are:

    1. PRESENT;

    2. The valid conditional votes, as defined by rules of power at least
       that of this rule; and

    3. For an instant runoff decision, the ordered lists of entities.

    4. For any other decision, the valid options.

==========================================================================

Reply via email to