Indictment Decision 00000000000002-A Resolved: That Cuddlebeam be convicted (found guilty) for Oathbreaking (pledge cited in evidence).
Indictment Decision 00000000000002-B Resolved: That the indictment fine of 3 blots, as issued by the Referee, be accepted. I hereby initiate a referendum on each of the above Decisions. Each decision has a voting method of AI-majority, with AI=1.5. The vote collector is the Arbitor, the quorum is 4, valid options are FOR and AGAINST (PRESENT is also a valid vote, as are conditional votes). Ordered pairs of votes for (A,B) above have the following meaning: (FOR, FOR) Guilty, and 3 blots is an appropriate penalty. (FOR, AGAINST) Guilty, but issue a different penalty (higher or lower). (AGAINST, FOR) Not Guilty, but if found guilty by total votes, 3 blots is appropriate. (AGAINST, AGAINST) Not Guilty, but if found guilty by total votes, issue a different penalty. EVIDENCE On 2/8/21 6:07 PM, Cuddle Beam via agora-business wrote: > I Point a Finger at Cuddlebeam for the crime of Oathbreaking for > breaking the Oath made below. > > On Tue, Feb 9, 2021 at 12:04 AM Cuddle Beam <cuddleb...@gmail.com> > wrote: > >> I pledge to give all of my VPs to Gaelan within 10 seconds of this >> message being published, with an N of Oathbreaking of 0. STATEMENT FOR THE PROSECUTION (by the Referee) > I issue an Indictment against Cuddlebeam for the above violation, > specifying a fine of 3 blots. > > I argue the Cuddlebeam ought to be convicted of this indictment because > e has clearly violated Rule 2450 - e has even pointed eir finger at > emself for doing so, meaning e has admitted the violation. In addition, > this was clearly done in an attempt to earn a Justice card for having > the most finger-pointings be resolved without Shenanigans, under Rule > 2478. The fine of 3 blots is appropriate in order to discourage em from > attempting such a stunt again, and to send a stern message to all > Agorans that such simple attempts to illegally profit must not be > tolerated. STATEMENT FOR THE DEFENSE: On 3/8/2021 1:02 AM, Cuddle Beam via agora-business wrote: > In my defense, I believe that the honorable Referee is being far too > generous. I insist that my punishment must be at least 20 blots, with a > further 10 blot penalty re-applied every month as community service so > that I can help propel the stagnant Justice Card economy and make amends > to the poor Agoran community. Only with a punishment of this magnitude - > and dare I say that even this much is almost insufficient - can true > Justice be imparted and the hearts of Agoran hearts all over the world > be put at peace. > > I rest my case.
