> On Sat, Feb 24, 2007 at 01:42:05AM -0500, Peter wrote: > > I intend on running the latest amavisd-new release with both clamav > > and a second av engine. I just can't decide on which. It is for a > > municipal organization. Is there another free-beer > solution or should > > I opt for a commercial solution. What are others doing in > this regard? >
I use McAfee's uvscan command line scanner as a second scanner; its pretty inexpensive, reliable (but not terribly fast). It rarely catches anything not already detected by my clamav, but the remaining content not already blocked by header checks, body checks, and file extension rejects is typically phishing or trojan downloader scripts. Here's a recent breakdown: 460 Malware by scanner ------------------------------------- 458 ClamAV-clamd 25 Html.Img.Gen013.Sanesecurity.06112900 19 Html.Phishing.Rock.Sanesecurity.06050500 16 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen175.Sanesecurity.06032008 13 Html.Phishing.Pay.Sanesecurity.06010900 12 HTML.Phishing.Pay-88 11 Html.Phishing.Azon.Gen034.Sanesecurity.06112900 9 HTML.Phishing.Bank-183 9 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen1021.Sanesecurity.06080700 9 Html.Phishing.Hex.Gen001.Sanesecurity.06041400 8 HTML.Phishing.Bank-362 8 HTML.Phishing.Bank-766 8 HTML.Phishing.Bank-826 8 HTML.Phishing.Pay-210 7 Html.Phishing.Card.Sanesecurity.06020300 7 Html.Phishing.Slw.Gen002.Sanesecurity.06021501 6 HTML.Phishing.Pay-128 6 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen033.Sanesecurity.06022705 6 Html.Phishing.Pay.Gen358.Sanesecurity.06091502 5 HTML.Phishing.Pay-178 5 Html.Img.Gen034.Sanesecurity.07010302 5 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen1542.Sanesecurity.06112912 5 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen438u.Sanesecurity.06041212 5 Html.Phishing.Pay.Gen007.Sanesecurity.06020900 5 Html.ScamL.Gen123.Sanesecurity.06082701 4 HTML.Phishing.Bank-28 4 HTML.Phishing.Bank-80 4 Html.Phishing.Azon.Gen003.Sanesecurity.06030800 4 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen194.Sanesecurity.06032200 4 Html.Phishing.Bank.Sanesecurity.06022304 4 Html.Phishing.Pay.Gen017.Sanesecurity.06022800 3 HTML.Phishing.Auction-243 3 HTML.Phishing.Auction-252 3 HTML.Phishing.Auction-282 3 HTML.Phishing.Bank-1101 3 HTML.Phishing.Bank-49 3 HTML.Phishing.Bank-973 3 Html.Phishing.Auction.Gen319.Sanesecurity.06111000 3 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen055.Sanesecurity.06030503 3 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen061.Sanesecurity.06030509 3 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen1031.Sanesecurity.06080804 3 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen1479.Sanesecurity.06111402 3 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen1712.Sanesecurity.07013101 3 Html.Phishing.Bank.Sanesecurity.05081600 3 Html.Phishing.Bank.Sanesecurity.06021701 3 Html.Phishing.Bank.Sanesecurity.06112903 3 Html.Phishing.Card.Sanesecurity.06022200 3 Worm.Stration.YY 2 HTML.Phishing.Acc-4 2 HTML.Phishing.Auction-202 2 HTML.Phishing.Azon-4 2 HTML.Phishing.Bank-1004 2 HTML.Phishing.Bank-1035 2 HTML.Phishing.Bank-213 2 HTML.Phishing.Bank-485 2 HTML.Phishing.Bank-651 2 HTML.Phishing.Bank-662 2 HTML.Phishing.Bank-771 2 HTML.Phishing.Bank-828 2 HTML.Phishing.Bank-917 2 HTML.Phishing.Card-41 2 HTML.Phishing.Pay-180 2 HTML.Phishing.Pay-38 2 HTML.Phishing.Pay-92 2 Html.Img.Gen055.Sanesecurity.07012201 2 Html.Phishing.Auction.Gen022.Sanesecurity.06022600 2 Html.Phishing.Auction.Gen035.Sanesecurity.06030804 2 Html.Phishing.Auction.Gen044.Sanesecurity.06030813 2 Html.Phishing.Auction.Gen302.Sanesecurity.06103000 2 Html.Phishing.Auction.Sanesecurity.06111802 2 Html.Phishing.Azon.Sanesecurity.06012600 2 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen015.Sanesecurity.06021800 2 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen075.Sanesecurity.06030703 2 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen078.Sanesecurity.06030706 2 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen101.Sanesecurity.06031001 2 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen1036.Sanesecurity.06080809 2 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen142.Sanesecurity.06031701 2 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen1609.Sanesecurity.06121900 2 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen458.Sanesecurity.06041315 2 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen496.Sanesecurity.06041803 2 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen845.Sanesecurity.06070708 2 Html.Phishing.Bank.Sanesecurity.06022201 2 Html.Phishing.Bank.Sanesecurity.06030605 2 Html.Phishing.Bank.Sanesecurity.06030703 2 Html.Phishing.Cur.Gen019.Sanesecurity.06071307 2 Html.Phishing.Pay.Gen015.Sanesecurity.06022700 2 Html.Phishing.Pay.Gen176.Sanesecurity.06051601 2 Html.Phishing.Pay.Gen328.Sanesecurity.06082200 2 Html.Phishing.Pay.Gen334.Sanesecurity.06082503 2 Html.Phishing.Pay.Gen391.Sanesecurity.06112402 2 Html.Phishing.Pay.Sanesecurity.06010901 1 Email.Phishing.Pay-5 1 Exploit.HTML.IFrame 1 HTML.Phishing.Auction-11 1 HTML.Phishing.Auction-145 1 HTML.Phishing.Auction-165 1 HTML.Phishing.Auction-179 1 HTML.Phishing.Auction-224 1 HTML.Phishing.Auction-271 1 HTML.Phishing.Auction-61 1 HTML.Phishing.Azon-17 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-1122 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-164 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-184 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-214 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-261 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-291 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-380 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-390 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-462 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-479 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-483 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-539 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-547 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-573 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-611 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-641 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-652 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-846 1 HTML.Phishing.Pay-101 1 HTML.Phishing.Pay-122 1 HTML.Phishing.Pay-131 1 HTML.Phishing.Pay-139 1 HTML.Phishing.Pay-152 1 HTML.Phishing.Pay-257 1 HTML.Phishing.Pay-51 1 HTML.Phishing.Pay-91 1 Html.Malware.Sanesecurity.06082100 1 Html.Phishing.Auction.Gen005.Sanesecurity.06012904 1 Html.Phishing.Auction.Gen008.Sanesecurity.06020101 1 Html.Phishing.Auction.Gen011.Sanesecurity.06020103 1 Html.Phishing.Auction.Gen018.Sanesecurity.06020801 1 Html.Phishing.Auction.Gen036.Sanesecurity.06030805 1 Html.Phishing.Auction.Gen056.Sanesecurity.06031300 1 Html.Phishing.Auction.Gen145.Sanesecurity.06060100 1 Html.Phishing.Auction.Gen209.Sanesecurity.06072501 1 Html.Phishing.Auction.Sanesecurity.06020100 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen032.Sanesecurity.06022704 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen1439.Sanesecurity.06110102 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen144.Sanesecurity.06031703 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen1569.Sanesecurity.06120807 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen1572.Sanesecurity.06120810 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen200.Sanesecurity.06032302 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen259.Sanesecurity.06032806 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen371.Sanesecurity.06040703 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen392.Sanesecurity.06040900 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen634.Sanesecurity.06051612 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen676.Sanesecurity.06052509 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Gen734.Sanesecurity.06060605 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Sanesecurity.06022006 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Sanesecurity.06022108 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Sanesecurity.06022401 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Sanesecurity.06022402 1 Html.Phishing.Bank.Sanesecurity.06120402 1 Html.Phishing.Card.Sanesecurity.06020303 1 Html.Phishing.Cur.Gen133.Sanesecurity.06092301 1 Html.Phishing.Cur.Gen189.Sanesecurity.06112002 1 Html.Phishing.Fake.Sanesecurity.06043001 1 Html.Phishing.Pay.Gen001.Sanesecurity.06012700 1 Html.Phishing.Pay.Gen013.Sanesecurity.06022200 1 Html.Phishing.Pay.Gen026.Sanesecurity.06030608 1 Html.Phishing.Pay.Gen065.Sanesecurity.06032203 1 Html.Phishing.Pay.Gen331.Sanesecurity.06082500 1 Html.Phishing.Pay.Gen374.Sanesecurity.06101700 1 Html.Phishing.Rdi.Gen063.Sanesecurity.06081600 1 Html.Phishing.Rdi.Gen064.Sanesecurity.06082100 1 Html.Phishing.Sanesecurity.TestSig 1 Html.ScamL.Gen002.Sanesecurity.06031701 1 Html.ScamL.Gen099.Sanesecurity.06060702 1 Trojan.Downloader.Small-2293 1 Trojan.Small-403 2 NAI McAfee AntiVirus (uvscan) 1 HTML.Phishing.Bank-1004 1 Trojan.Downloader.Small-2293 MrC ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Take Surveys. Earn Cash. Influence the Future of IT Join SourceForge.net's Techsay panel and you'll get the chance to share your opinions on IT & business topics through brief surveys-and earn cash http://www.techsay.com/default.php?page=join.php&p=sourceforge&CID=DEVDEV _______________________________________________ AMaViS-user mailing list AMaViS-user@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/amavis-user AMaViS-FAQ:http://www.amavis.org/amavis-faq.php3 AMaViS-HowTos:http://www.amavis.org/howto/